Nerve gas deployed by V-1
-
- Member
- Posts: 784
- Joined: 23 Mar 2004, 01:25
- Location: Wellington, New Zealand
Nerve gas deployed by V-1
Commencing in August 1943 production began on Tabun-B at Dyrhrenfurth near Breslau. Tabun-B had a greater shelf life and was easier to handle than Tabun-A. Prisoners from Gross Rosen were tasked to start filling aerial bombs and artillery shells with the nerve agent. Work also commenced at a factory in Breslau on manufacture of prototypes of the V-1 and V-2 with warheads for the nerve gas.
It seems from what I have read in several sources that about the time of the July 1944 Bomb Plot against Hitler threats were conveyed to Hitler that Churchill would use Anthrax in retaliation and USA would use nuclear weapons against Dresden. This unnerved Hitler into abandoning use of Tabun-B, but what if he hadn't given in?
What if:
1) Germany used Tabun-B artillery shells against Soviets
2) Deployed Tabun-B via artillery and aerial bombs over Normandy beaches
3) Deployed Tabun-B against England by V-1 or V-2
It seems from what I have read in several sources that about the time of the July 1944 Bomb Plot against Hitler threats were conveyed to Hitler that Churchill would use Anthrax in retaliation and USA would use nuclear weapons against Dresden. This unnerved Hitler into abandoning use of Tabun-B, but what if he hadn't given in?
What if:
1) Germany used Tabun-B artillery shells against Soviets
2) Deployed Tabun-B via artillery and aerial bombs over Normandy beaches
3) Deployed Tabun-B against England by V-1 or V-2
-
- Member
- Posts: 3533
- Joined: 24 Apr 2006, 22:21
- Location: Michigan U.S.A.
The Allies Retaliate in Kind
The Allies would retaliate using mustard gas. Not as deadly as Tabun but plenty bad enough.
-
- Member
- Posts: 784
- Joined: 23 Mar 2004, 01:25
- Location: Wellington, New Zealand
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
True they would but say for example if it was used at Normandy?
Take a read of this article:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... lions.html
German troops along the Atlantic Wall defences could easily have been equipped with gas masks and protection against mustard gas. Why weren't they prepared to use it to throw the Allies back into the sea?
Take a read of this article:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... lions.html
German troops along the Atlantic Wall defences could easily have been equipped with gas masks and protection against mustard gas. Why weren't they prepared to use it to throw the Allies back into the sea?
- Markus Becker
- Member
- Posts: 641
- Joined: 27 Apr 2005, 18:09
- Location: Germany
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
They have been there and done that in WW1. With the result of everbody getting more miserable and nobody getting an advantage. And it also helped that the Wehrmacht units that defended Normandy were apparently far less prepared for CW than the allied ones.
- Terry Duncan
- Forum Staff
- Posts: 6270
- Joined: 13 Jun 2008, 23:54
- Location: Kent
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
Anthrax and nukes are a good possibility, there were a lot of rather unpleasant weapons around to use, not just the old WWI gasses like mustard gas and phosgene. There are a few interesting details at the following site;
http://hitlernews.cloudworth.com/chemic ... f-wwII.php
http://hitlernews.cloudworth.com/chemic ... f-wwII.php
There was an idea the allies may have developed even worse weapons already, as Germany had only started relatively late in this field after WWI. Anthrax for example could leave vast areas too dangerous to live in for years, and mass delivery over Germany was not an issue by this time in the war.Why weren't they prepared to use it to throw the Allies back into the sea?
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
Claims that the Allies threatened Germany with anthrax and atomic weapons have no base in fact.Kiwikid wrote:It seems from what I have read in several sources that about the time of the July 1944 Bomb Plot against Hitler threats were conveyed to Hitler that Churchill would use Anthrax in retaliation and USA would use nuclear weapons against Dresden. This unnerved Hitler into abandoning use of Tabun-B, but what if he hadn't given in?
-
- Member
- Posts: 3533
- Joined: 24 Apr 2006, 22:21
- Location: Michigan U.S.A.
throw the Allies back into the sea?
That's entirely possible at Normandy but then there would be hell to pay. Neither PM Churchill nor President FDR had a problem with slaughtering German civilians. The Anglo-American reply would be to dump mustard gas on major German cities like Hamburg and Berlin.
- phylo_roadking
- Member
- Posts: 17488
- Joined: 01 May 2006, 00:31
- Location: Belfast
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_VegetarianClaims that the Allies threatened Germany with anthrax....have no basis in fact
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gruinard_I ... re_testing
The existence of weaponised Anthrax in the British armoury was IIRC communicated to the Germans via Switzerland in late 1942.
Last edited by phylo_roadking on 23 Oct 2010, 21:52, edited 1 time in total.
Twenty years ago we had Johnny Cash, Bob Hope and Steve Jobs. Now we have no Cash, no Hope and no Jobs....
Lord, please keep Kevin Bacon alive...
Lord, please keep Kevin Bacon alive...
- Markus Becker
- Member
- Posts: 641
- Joined: 27 Apr 2005, 18:09
- Location: Germany
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
Ohh hell, just when you think you have seen it all something like this comes around the corner.phylo_roadking wrote: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Vegetarian
One more addition to the list of really stupid ideas.
- phylo_roadking
- Member
- Posts: 17488
- Joined: 01 May 2006, 00:31
- Location: Belfast
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
Really "really stupid"....?One more addition to the list of really stupid ideas
Did the British have the weaponised Anthrax?
Yes
Did the British have the prepared "munitions?" (incidently, the Guinard experiment as you can see ALSO tested "conventional" ordnance for delivery...)
Yes
Did they have a thousand bombers capable of reaching Germany on a good night?
Yes
In other words - whether it would have worked or not - the Germans had to face the prospect that it had been developed, had been tested AND the British could deliver it.
Do you honestly think that THEN they'd put the British to the test??? One throw of the dice - and IF it worked, Germany was a desert.
Just like the Cold War and nuclear weapons....it's about deterrence Not use.
Last edited by phylo_roadking on 23 Oct 2010, 23:11, edited 1 time in total.
Twenty years ago we had Johnny Cash, Bob Hope and Steve Jobs. Now we have no Cash, no Hope and no Jobs....
Lord, please keep Kevin Bacon alive...
Lord, please keep Kevin Bacon alive...
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
The Germans feared overwhelming Allied retaliation against German cities to use chemical agents.
Why the fixation on non-persistent nerve agent? Mustard is still a good gas in different situations. One, it is persistent, and two, it causes wounds that are difficult heal.
Penn44
.
Why the fixation on non-persistent nerve agent? Mustard is still a good gas in different situations. One, it is persistent, and two, it causes wounds that are difficult heal.
Given that the Germans were on the defensive, in general, mustard would have been the agent of choice. However, GA could have supported local German counterattacks.Kiwikid wrote:1) Germany used Tabun-B artillery shells against Soviets
Mustard would have also been an effective weapon.Kiwikid wrote:2) Deployed Tabun-B via artillery and aerial bombs over Normandy beaches
Being a volatile non-persistent agent, I don’t know whether the V-1 or V-2 would have been an effective a delivery means among other reasons.Kiwikid wrote:3) Deployed Tabun-B against England by V-1 or V-2
Penn44
.
I once was told that I was vain, but I knew that vanity was a fault, so I gave it up because I have no faults.
- Markus Becker
- Member
- Posts: 641
- Joined: 27 Apr 2005, 18:09
- Location: Germany
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
And very soon later the UK would be a desert too. In 42 the LW could reach the UK just as well. So send back some of the anthrax cakes, add some CW and you are back where you were in WW1.phylo_roadking wrote: Do you honestly think that THEN they'd put the British to the test??? One throw of the dice - and IF it worked, Germany was a desert.
About deterrence, the UK had no idea the Germans had nerve gases but both the UK and Germany knew the other side had a arsenal of CW and the means to deploy them. Deterrence was already achived.
- phylo_roadking
- Member
- Posts: 17488
- Joined: 01 May 2006, 00:31
- Location: Belfast
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
Yes - but there's absolutely nothing wrong with copperfastening it. Either side would of course want to think/that they were the ones driving the agreement not to escalate to that level, that they were controlling the balance...not the other guy. The more rungs there are on the escalation ladder, the more the stakes are raised by the possession of ever more deadly weapons and ever more simple ways of deploying them...the higher the stakes gradually become...then the more reliable is the deterrence to even stepping on the ladder.About deterrence, the UK had no idea the Germans had nerve gases but both the UK and Germany knew the other side had a arsenal of CW and the means to deploy them. Deterrence was already achived.
Really? Did they have the capacity to launch 1,000-bomber raids against the UK? I thought they were busier to the East...In 42 the LW could reach the UK just as well.
Twenty years ago we had Johnny Cash, Bob Hope and Steve Jobs. Now we have no Cash, no Hope and no Jobs....
Lord, please keep Kevin Bacon alive...
Lord, please keep Kevin Bacon alive...
-
- Member
- Posts: 3533
- Joined: 24 Apr 2006, 22:21
- Location: Michigan U.S.A.
Mustard would have also been an effective weapon
If Germany is foolish or desperate enough to use chemical weapons they should wait until winter. And there's little point in waiting until December 1944. The Luftwaffe could begin dropping Tabun filled bombs at night during December 1943.
HD (Distilled Mustard) is ineffective in winter due to having a relativley high freezing point. Consequently HD is normally mixed with something like Lewisite during the winter to lower the freezing point. This helps but any Mustard gas mixture is a poor choice during cold weather.
GA (Tabun) is an entirely different matter. The freezing point is so low that you could probably use it effectively in Antarctica. Winter time temperatures would just make it more effective by making it more persistent.
HD (Distilled Mustard) is ineffective in winter due to having a relativley high freezing point. Consequently HD is normally mixed with something like Lewisite during the winter to lower the freezing point. This helps but any Mustard gas mixture is a poor choice during cold weather.
GA (Tabun) is an entirely different matter. The freezing point is so low that you could probably use it effectively in Antarctica. Winter time temperatures would just make it more effective by making it more persistent.
- Markus Becker
- Member
- Posts: 641
- Joined: 27 Apr 2005, 18:09
- Location: Germany
Re: Nerve gas deployed by V-1
First, the UK´s 1.000 bomber raid on Cologone included planes from the Costal Command and even OTU and still fell short of the 1.000 mark.phylo_roadking wrote:
Really? Did they have the capacity to launch 1,000-bomber raids against the UK? I thought they were busier to the East...
Second, yes the LW was busy elsewhere but trust me, if it had started raining anthrax on Germany the priorities would have changed. After all, there soon would have been nothing worth defending any more, so one can use the time one has left to turn the attacker´s coutry into a desert too.
edit: I´d get it if the Brits had played with this idea in 1940 but 42? Whatever crisis they had been in was long over.