Republicans, but not Reds
One question that has some interest in my opinion is were all Republicans really "Reds"? I came up to this problem when I made a study of Basque nationalism and about PNV (Partido Nacionalista Vasco) some years ago. The Basque nationalists fought for the Republic in the Spanish Civil War, but they can not be called as "Reds" by any measure. For what I know Basque Nationalism at that time was conservative catholic party based on the principles of it´s founder, very religious Sabino Arana Goiri. Even today I would consider PNV to be a Christian Democratic party.
Both Basque and Catalan nationalists fought for the Republicans, as the Republic had guaranteed the autonomy for both the Basque Country and Catalonia. Their alliance with leftist and extremeleftist parties of the Republicans was not an easy one, but it was considered lesser evil than what Franco offered (abolition of autonomy, public denial and persecution of "separatism" and to forbid the use of the both euskara and catalan languages).
A small, but interesting "bourgeois" element in Republican Army were the Spanish protestants. Some of them enlisted to Republican army because the Republic had guaranteed the freedom of religion. The very strong catholicism of the Spanish Nationalist camp made Spanish Protestants to do the same choice as Basque and Catalan nationalists: the Republic was lesser evil than the ultracatholicism supported by various elements of Franco´s coalition.
This makes me to think that there should at last be some book or article referring to this side of history. I feel a bit angry when I hear even today someone referring the Basque priests as "Red priests" due to their action during the Spanish Civil History. They were not Red, they were supporting Basque nationalism.
By the same token it does not make justice to call all the supporters of Franco simply as "fascists". There were various elements (traditional conservatives, monarchists, carlists, falangists) in his camp and there were discrepancies among them. I would not even consider Franco himself as a fascist but as a hardline catholic conservative. And he was also a Spanish nationalist in the strong unitarist way. He could not accept any compromises with Basque or Catalan nationalists.
The simplifying labels "Reds" and "Fascists" influenced very much the foreign volunteers who fought on both sides in Spanish Civil War. If you read their memoirs, the enemy is almost always "Red" or "Fascist". But the truth was not so simple.
Bourgeois Republicans?
Discussions on all aspects of the Spanish Civil War including the Condor Legion, the Germans fighting for Franco in the Spanish Civil War.
Post Reply
1 post
• Page 1 of 1
Return to “Spanish Civil War & Legion Condor”
Jump to
- Axis History
- ↳ Life in the Third Reich & Weimar Republic
- ↳ Propaganda, Culture & Architecture
- ↳ Music of the Reich
- ↳ Women in the Reich
- ↳ Heer, Waffen-SS & Fallschirmjäger
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ U-Boats
- ↳ Kriegsmarine surface ships and Kriegsmarine in general
- ↳ Luftwaffe air units and Luftwaffe in general
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Legion Condor
- ↳ German Strategy & General German Military Discussion
- ↳ NSDAP, other party organizations & Government
- ↳ The Phil Nix SS & Polizei section
- ↳ The Dieter Zinke Axis Biographical Research Section
- ↳ Japan at War 1895-1945
- ↳ Italy under Fascism 1922-1945
- ↳ Minor Axis Nations
- ↳ Finland
- ↳ Foreign Volunteers & Collaboration
- ↳ Holocaust & 20th Century War Crimes
- Axis Equipment
- ↳ Aircraft
- ↳ Fortifications, Artillery, & Rockets
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ The Ron Klages Panzer & other vehicles Section
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Panzer & other vehicles - Photo threads
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Small Arms
- ↳ Other Equipment
- Militaria & Collecting
- ↳ Axis Awards
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ Axis Documents, Feldpost numbers, Postcards & Other Paper Items
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ Axis Uniforms, Headgear & Insignia
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ Other WW1 & WW2 Militaria
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ For Sale & Wanted
- ↳ Reproductions Sales
- The Allies & the Neutral States
- ↳ China at War 1895-1949
- ↳ France 1919-1945
- ↳ Poland 1919-1945
- ↳ The Soviet Union at War 1917-1945
- ↳ The United Kingdom & its Empire and Commonwealth 1919-45
- ↳ USA 1919-1945
- ↳ The Allies and the Neutral States in general
- World War II and Inter-War Era
- ↳ WW2 in Africa & the Mediterranean
- ↳ WW2 in Eastern Europe
- ↳ WW2 in Western Europe & the Atlantic
- ↳ WW2 in the Pacific & Asia
- ↳ Winter War & Continuation War
- ↳ Spanish Civil War & Legion Condor
- ↳ Economy
- Other Eras
- ↳ First World War
- ↳ Imperial Germany
- ↳ German Colonies and Overseas Expeditions
- ↳ Austria-Hungary 1867–1918
- ↳ The end of the Ottoman Empire 1908-1923
- ↳ Other eras
- Research Help
- ↳ Translation help: Breaking the Sound Barrier
- ↳ Books & other Reference Material
- ↳ Archives
- Other areas
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Movies, games & other fiction
- ↳ What if
- ↳ Reenactment
- ↳ The Lounge