This is an apolitical forum for discussions on the Axis nations, as well as the First and Second World Wars in general hosted by Marcus Wendel's Axis History Factbook in cooperation with Michael Miller's Axis Biographical Research and Christoph Awender's WW2 day by day.




CJK1990 wrote:It sure seems like it. Not sure how else to explain the fact that there was a huge resistance movement against the Germans while there virtually no resistance at all against the Allies, even though they were the invaders who brought the war to Italy itself.

CJK1990 wrote:It sure seems like it. Not sure how else to explain the fact that there was a huge resistance movement against the Germans while there virtually no resistance at all against the Allies, even though they were the invaders who brought the war to Italy itself.



Trackhead M2 wrote:Dear Pm,
You seem to be confusing a pro-Facist paramilitary militia with a "resistance' movement. There was a Mussolini government (active and puppet) until 1945. So, the forces you mention are just Mussolini loyalists and not a resistance. The Sicilian resistance you speak of was one that resisted foreigners and saw the Mussolini government the way the former Confederate States in the USA saw the US Government as "Damn Yankees". So the use of the term resistance to the allies by forces loyal to what was the "government" is not correct.
Strike Swiftly,
TH-M2





Oasis wrote:I'd like to see the sources of Panzermahn.
The volunteers for fighting with RSI were in a certain number only to escape from Germany (i.e. div. Monterosa) and at the arrive in Italy a lot disappeared... often joining partisans...
About "gangs" if Badoglio ever had one, what to say about Mussolini? The honour of Italy (which one?) was invoked by a small part of fascists that principally fought partisans and were very very partially involved against allied forces, as Germans did not believe in them...
What do you mean about "illegal partisan activities"? They were called "banditen" and all their activities against nazi-fascists were considered illegal by them: only at the moment of surrender - toward the end of the war - they were often considered as fighting army by the axis forces.
Please don't be so "pretty sure" about italian rural folks "forced" to support "nuisance" partisans: they did support partisans, without their help and cooperation the partisan movement should have been in hard difficulties: they were called patriots, when not directly involved as partisans. And there were also fascist party partners, of course, that helped fascists and nazi troops to capture partisans and their supporters (in many cases elder people, women and children, "simply" massacred by SS and WH troops with the help of Black Brigade)... what about the "honour of Italy"... and there could be many other things to say, always with respect of all opinions, but not of suppositions or unfounded beliefs.

Panzermahn wrote:Oasis wrote:I'd like to see the sources of Panzermahn.
The volunteers for fighting with RSI were in a certain number only to escape from Germany (i.e. div. Monterosa) and at the arrive in Italy a lot disappeared... often joining partisans...
About "gangs" if Badoglio ever had one, what to say about Mussolini? The honour of Italy (which one?) was invoked by a small part of fascists that principally fought partisans and were very very partially involved against allied forces, as Germans did not believe in them...
What do you mean about "illegal partisan activities"? They were called "banditen" and all their activities against nazi-fascists were considered illegal by them: only at the moment of surrender - toward the end of the war - they were often considered as fighting army by the axis forces.
Please don't be so "pretty sure" about italian rural folks "forced" to support "nuisance" partisans: they did support partisans, without their help and cooperation the partisan movement should have been in hard difficulties: they were called patriots, when not directly involved as partisans. And there were also fascist party partners, of course, that helped fascists and nazi troops to capture partisans and their supporters (in many cases elder people, women and children, "simply" massacred by SS and WH troops with the help of Black Brigade)... what about the "honour of Italy"... and there could be many other things to say, always with respect of all opinions, but not of suppositions or unfounded beliefs.
Hello Oasis
Apologies for late reply. I start with English sources like Perry Biddiscombe's excellent The SS Hunter Battalions (Tempus 2006) and Nicholas Farell's Mussolini: A New Life (2004). I had a couple of testimonies from veterans from the UNCRSI (National Association of RSI veterans). Giorgio Pisano's book on the Triangle of Death (at Reggio Emilia) as well as Renzo de Felice's last volume (from the multivolume history on Fascism and Mussolini, and bear in mind that de Felice was also a hardcore communist, who changed his views AFTER the end of the war) on the Italian Civil War from 1943-45 would be a good start
I don't deny some Italians joined the RSI to escape from the internment at the hands of the Germans. But you can't deny that there are Italians who were neither fascist or communists joined the RSI to salvage the honour of Italy. It was after the armistice of 1943 that many the Axis nations look Italy in contempt due to the betrayal of Marshal Badoglio. Another case would be the famous ex-bolshevik Nicolla Bombacci. Bombacci was a die-hard Bolshevik, but when Mussolini announced his RSI in 1943, Bombacci joined him because he knew that it was the Mussolini's social ideas were the correct socialism as compared with the Bolshevik's internationalism-based socialism. And true to his word, Bombacci stay to the very end with Mussolini and paid for his life when he was hanged updside together with the Duce in Piazza Loretto in 1945
You said that the Italian rural folks supported the partisans. Try asking that to the Govoni family who was slaughtered mercilessly by them. How about Norma Cossetto infamous murder? There is a topic in AHF regarding the atrocities of the Italian partisans (they even murdered other partisans who did not share their own political ideas)
Are you forgetting that the Italian partisans had their own agenda of a proletarian revolution (there are partisan republics created by the Italian partisans, such as the infamous Partisan Republic of Montefiorino), to grab the power from the legitimate Italian government after the end of the war? The American and the British knew it, that's why with their determination, Italy was never ruled by the Bolsheviks
Panzermahn




Return to Italy under Fascism 1922-1945
Users browsing this forum: CommonCrawl [Bot] and 1 guest