Soviet Naval Battles

Discussions on all aspects of the USSR, from the Russian Civil War till the end of the Great Patriotic War and the war against Japan. Hosted by Art.
Post Reply
lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#601

Post by lupodimare89 » 08 Sep 2014, 12:02

Thank you again for the replies
(ps i've finally started to read your own ktb records on your blog-page. It take me long time due slowness of the translator, but i will finish it, it's only 1941 and 1942?)
I don't know exact name. It taken from german docs and in different docs one name may be spelled in different way. Germans somethimes misspelled norwegian names very hard.
I've checked online and the correct name SHOULD be Storegga, from the natural underwater landslides
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storegga_Slide

6 September
R-304 sank east of "Ekeroe" (i guess it's Ekkeroy) after striking a mine.

Who could have laid the mine?
Mines was laid by TKA Nrs 172, 192, 213, 214.


This is very much interesting!
It's the first time we've seen here a target that we can now lists among the victims of Soviet MTBs due mines.
(i'm pretty much sure there are also in Baltic Sea and Black Sea, but i've long delayed these research because they're a bit messed up).
Well surely it's the first we've seen now in Arctic.
When they laid the mines, and how many?

It's also interesting because appears to be the main shared result achieved by the transferred units of D-3 class (172 and 192)

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#602

Post by lupodimare89 » 20 Sep 2014, 10:55

Sorry the long delay (had study for univers.)

I've finished checking October 1944. This is the last English KTB that i have.
After this we could fill the gap of some details in minelaying in Arctic, and try to check some interesting things in Baltic.


1 October.
KTB report the attack on LOFOTEN by K-2 (on 30 Sept).
We know that attack failed (also gunfire), however the KTB say "The submarine fired two torpedoes that ruined the target."
That "ruined" is possibly a translation-mistake?


On day 3 October it reports that on 2 October at 23.10h.
6 boats of 21st motor minesweepers fought 3 Russian MTBs northeast of Ekkeroy.
One Soviet MTBs claimed as probably destroyed, 2 others claimed as damaged.
No mention of German own damage or casualties.


I've an old data that report on 10 October 1944 the loss of "Kohlenshiff Stor" (665 GRT) sunk at Kirkenes by MTBs
http://www.schiffswrackliste.de/BRT%201944.htm
Never mentioned in other lists of sources i've read.

Worth to say that the KTB describe a little how German minesweepers made "discontinued" attempts to attack the Soviet landing at Sonja Hill (petsamo Fjord), due the heavy weather and rough sea. They were attempting to attack soviet landing craft? there is knowledge of a contact?

No other details are given of these operations, however on 11 October it's say that several German and Norwegian vessels were damaged or sunk by air raids: not all of them are given the name (so the "Stor" could be among them).

Also it's worth to say that in this last KTB it appears clear how poor details are given: most of the focus is given to Baltic Sea.



On the attack of 12 October 1944 and sinking of M-303 i can adds that the Germans identified 7 attacking MTbs (while there were 3). Also the chief of 22nd minesweeper Flottilla was onboard M-303, but he and other 25 were rescued.



13 october
h 21.00 At Ekkeroey
German gunboat K-3 claim to have sunk 2 MTB in a fight against 6 to 8 MTBs

It's also reported that previously, on evening of 11 October, 21st motor minesweeper flotilla claim to have destroyed 1 and probably another 1 destroyed MTB at Kyberg. But that wasn't the fight with M-303 sinking, or yes?


On 16 october reports that
On Afternoon of 14 October: 2 Soviet MTBs shelled strongpoints of Jacobselv station
Noon of 16 October: German convoy repelled a Soviet MTBs attack: one attacking MTb was claimed sunk, another shot afire, a third one damaged.
Interesting that say shortly after this that patrol position east of Kirkenes were attacked 3 times by ten planes: V-6706 sunk during the attack and AF-24 that move close to assistance and drove away 3 MTBs of Kar Fjord, and damaged one of them seriously

How were done the Soviet attacks? MTBs and aircraft attacked together or were different hour and place?


17 october
AF-24 claim to have sunk in Holmangraaf Fjord an enemy MTB

20 October
AF-24 claim to have sunk in Holmengraa Fjord an enemy MTB (identical claim of 17 October, probably separated).

21 October 1944
Some details of this last successful attack: Germans claimed "several" attacking MTBs damaged (while we know only TKA-230 was). Confirmed that R-311 was in need to be towed after torpedo hit (i've never understood if torpedo properly exploded or it was a violent dud hit). Apart the loss of M-31, it say also that R-151 was sunk from the same convoy, but shortly after (06.33h, M-31 loss was at 02.26) by air attack.


23 October
It say that in the evening of 22Oct. 3 MTBs attacked but beaten back by convoy that left Kirkenes.

25 October
Loss of merchant JARNBARDEN by mine: http://www.warsailors.com/homefleet/shipsj.html#Ja http://warsailors.com/forum/read.php?1, ... 9#msg-4059
I've found the explain and discussion of M.Morozov about it: mines of L-20 had to self-detonate earlier, still possible merchant was sunk by drifting mine from L-22 field or German own defensive field.
Probably, being unconfirmed/not enough evidence, he didn't added it to the list.


No clear details or evaluation of Soviet destroyer bombing on 26 October.
It's said however they were identified the next days, on sea.



All the Submarine victories are neatly confirmed: Lumme, V-1220 and V-1219.
No confirmation (as expected) of the mysterious victory of V-4 against a target on 18 October.


igorr
Member
Posts: 852
Joined: 29 Aug 2009, 03:21

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#603

Post by igorr » 20 Sep 2014, 11:31

lupodimare89 wrote: 1 October.
KTB report the attack on LOFOTEN by K-2 (on 30 Sept).
We know that attack failed (also gunfire), however the KTB say "The submarine fired two torpedoes that ruined the target."
That "ruined" is possibly a translation-mistake?
K-2 was sunk in 1942. LOFOTEN was attacked near Bodo by SATYR and torpedoes miss the ship.
I've an old data that report on 10 October 1944 the loss of "Kohlenshiff Stor" (665 GRT) sunk at Kirkenes by MTBs
http://www.schiffswrackliste.de/BRT%201944.htm
Never mentioned in other lists of sources i've read.
STOER was sunk by Il-2 11.10.44 in Kirkenes, but this was small coastal M/S 106 brt, not that of 665 brt.
Worth to say that the KTB describe a little how German minesweepers made "discontinued" attempts to attack the Soviet landing at Sonja Hill (petsamo Fjord), due the heavy weather and rough sea. They were attempting to attack soviet landing craft? there is knowledge of a contact?
Yes R.152, 156 and 160 out to investigate, but returned due to strong sea (8/10).
Also it's worth to say that in this last KTB it appears clear how poor details are given: most of the focus is given to Baltic Sea.
Most german docs for 10.44 from Kirkenes area didn't survive war.
It's also reported that previously, on evening of 11 October, 21st motor minesweeper flotilla claim to have destroyed 1 and probably another 1 destroyed MTB at Kyberg. But that wasn't the fight with M-303 sinking, or yes?
Same clash. There was two convoys simulateously in one place.
How were done the Soviet attacks? MTBs and aircraft attacked together or were different hour and place?
Not togheter. TKA's was sent to finish crippled enemy, but they can't.
17 october
AF-24 claim to have sunk in Holmangraaf Fjord an enemy MTB
20 October
AF-24 claim to have sunk in Holmengraa Fjord an enemy MTB (identical claim of 17 October, probably separated).
Only at 17th.
21 October 1944
i've never understood if torpedo properly exploded or it was a violent dud hit
Of course dud.
No clear details or evaluation of Soviet destroyer bombing on 26 October.
It's said however they were identified the next days, on sea.
Some minor hits in village, bataries and haven. No casualties.

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#604

Post by lupodimare89 » 24 Sep 2014, 10:18

Thanks again, (and sorry for the first mistake).

As promised, now we could fill some gaps about the the minelaying operations in Arctic.

We've few little things remained with some holes.

More on specific, the identity of the MO-4 units that laid the folliwing mines:



The field of 12 November 1941.
Especially the 30 mines laid at Petsamo, linked with the loss of merchant Utlandshorn in 16 March 1942
Who laid the mines?


Same question for the mines laid on 12 November 1942, responsable of sinking of Schiff-18 (on 19 November).
Reading your ktb, it's wrote that there were 9 boats (escorted by TKA 13 and 14) in 3 groups, laying 18 mines.
Same mines were also responsable for loss of Westsee and Hans Rickmers (finished by artillery).


Still on november, the damaging of Akka. Who laid the mines responsable? and when?

Once again same question for the minelaying of 30 November 1942, responsable of loss of V-5909. Who laid the mines?

Final one is the sinking of the famous Antje Fritzen, on 21 September 1943.
Who laid the mines and when?

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#605

Post by lupodimare89 » 24 Sep 2014, 10:23

In addition there is also the fate of a ship that i've read as "sunk by soviet mines".

The famous merchant NATAL (3172 GRT), often targetened by Soviet submarines (as wreck), that's reported as sunk off Altafjord on 7 January 1944.

I've not confirmation of the location, Altafjord seems a bit far from the MO-4 range. However on uboat.net reports the attack against the wreck done by M-104 and M-201 as having occurred in Makkaur.

Clearly there is a mistake about the location.

igorr
Member
Posts: 852
Joined: 29 Aug 2009, 03:21

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#606

Post by igorr » 25 Sep 2014, 05:17

lupodimare89 wrote:The field of 12 November 1941.
Especially the 30 mines laid at Petsamo, linked with the loss of merchant Utlandshorn in 16 March 1942
Who laid the mines?
There was no fields laid on 12.11.41. First time of laying mines on Petsamo entrance was 7.12.41 (2x2 mines KB from MO Nrs. 153 ad 163), second 21.1.42 when same boats + Nrs. 122 and 123 try to lay mines there. They was sighted and shelled, can lay only 4 mines out from 8. Which mines exactly hit Utlandshorn can't be ruled.
Same question for the mines laid on 12 November 1942, responsable of sinking of Schiff-18 (on 19 November).
Reading your ktb, it's wrote that there were 9 boats (escorted by TKA 13 and 14) in 3 groups, laying 18 mines.
Same mines were also responsable for loss of Westsee and Hans Rickmers (finished by artillery).
This was 2 different fields. One from 12.11 responsible for W. and HR, true. But SCHIFF 18 sunk on different field, laid by 10 MO's in night 18/19.11. This was not Petsamo, but near Kirkenes.
Still on november, the damaging of Akka. Who laid the mines responsable? and when?
This must be some drifting german mine... Soviet ships didn't lay mines there in appropriate time.
Once again same question for the minelaying of 30 November 1942, responsable of loss of V-5909. Who laid the mines?
7 MO's. In all three last cases i don't know exact names.
Final one is the sinking of the famous Antje Fritzen, on 21 September 1943.
Who laid the mines and when?
It's no possible to calculate exact field and date. Oe of that laid in 11.02-06.04.43.

igorr
Member
Posts: 852
Joined: 29 Aug 2009, 03:21

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#607

Post by igorr » 25 Sep 2014, 05:21

lupodimare89 wrote: In addition there is also the fate of a ship that i've read as "sunk by soviet mines".
The famous merchant NATAL (3172 GRT), often targetened by Soviet submarines (as wreck), that's reported as sunk off Altafjord on 7 January 1944.
I've not confirmation of the location, Altafjord seems a bit far from the MO-4 range. However on uboat.net reports the attack against the wreck done by M-104 and M-201 as having occurred in Makkaur.
Clearly there is a mistake about the location.
Strange to read such things. Ship was throw at rocks by gale and broke in half near cape Makkaur, far away from Alta. No mines!

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#608

Post by lupodimare89 » 01 Oct 2014, 10:43

Thanks for all the details ( i had forgot to record the details of Akka fate).

About the Natal i was sure it was wrong, but still its' worth to check if there are some weird claim-data

Speaking of this here some last ones that i believe are clearly WRONG:


I've a strange line that claim for March 1943 that
"Before the Petsamo German auxiliary minesweeper M 5607 fall (on 27.3.) And M 5608(on 28.3.). on mines, the first-mentioned can be recovered later. "
For M-5608 we've seen that it was actually 29 March 1942 (and was due mines dropped by bombers).
But what about M-5607? I've failed to find other mentions to this one
(the original source was wlb-stuttgart.de)

Other ones are the loss of norwegian coaster Engoy, occurred on 6 March 1943 at "Sunnfjodleia" i believe it's "Sunnfjord", so it's very south.


On 20 July 1943 i've found V-6114 reported as "sunk by Soviet submarine", and wrecksite even say it was S-56
http://www.wrecksite.eu/wreck.aspx?151820
But if i'm right, the attack on convoy that day failed, i've not found other data about this german patrol ship.
I've only found this other attack http://historisches-marinearchiv.de/pro ... var2=wert2 mentioned as failed, by ShCh-403


Another interesting data from wlb-stuttgart.de it's this:
"Am 27.10. wird Minenräumschiff MRS 26 durch einen sowj. Marineflieger (Typ ex-amerik. A-20) im Hopseidet (westl. Arm des Tanafjordes) versenkt.At 27.10. is (the western arm Tanafjordes) Hopseidet mine sweeping vessel sunk in 26 MRS sowj by a naval aviator (type ex-American. A-20)."
Stating the loss (on 1944) of the MRS-26 by soviet mine laid by A-20 aircraft.


One last strange event it's related to submarine U-295
" U 295 wird am 24.1. durch Minentreffer beschädigt."
On January 1945
On HM it's confirmed only as place din "AC-85" http://historisches-marinearchiv.de/pro ... var2=wert2

igorr
Member
Posts: 852
Joined: 29 Aug 2009, 03:21

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#609

Post by igorr » 02 Oct 2014, 05:31

lupodimare89 wrote: I've a strange line that claim for March 1943 that
"Before the Petsamo German auxiliary minesweeper M 5607 fall (on 27.3.) And M 5608(on 28.3.). on mines, the first-mentioned can be recovered later. "
For M-5608 we've seen that it was actually 29 March 1942 (and was due mines dropped by bombers).
But what about M-5607? I've failed to find other mentions to this one
(the original source was wlb-stuttgart.de)
Stange indeed. M.5607 was destroyed 4.8.44 in Hamburg and no other sinkings about her. No data about her in Petsamo in march 1943 or march 1942.
Other ones are the loss of norwegian coaster Engoy, occurred on 6 March 1943 at "Sunnfjodleia" i believe it's "Sunnfjord", so it's very south.
Near Floroy
On 20 July 1943 i've found V-6114 reported as "sunk by Soviet submarine", and wrecksite even say it was S-56
http://www.wrecksite.eu/wreck.aspx?151820
V.6114 on 20.7.43 was on Tromso Werft for cleaning up her boilers.
Another interesting data from wlb-stuttgart.de it's this:
"Am 27.10. wird Minenräumschiff MRS 26 durch einen sowj. Marineflieger (Typ ex-amerik. A-20) im Hopseidet (westl. Arm des Tanafjordes) versenkt.At 27.10. is (the western arm Tanafjordes) Hopseidet mine sweeping vessel sunk in 26 MRS sowj by a naval aviator (type ex-American. A-20)."
Stating the loss (on 1944) of the MRS-26 by soviet mine laid by A-20 aircraft.
Bad translation. MRS.26 was indeed sunk by Bostons. But they used bombs (500kg).
One last strange event it's related to submarine U-295
" U 295 wird am 24.1. durch Minentreffer beschädigt."
On January 1945
On HM it's confirmed only as place din "AC-85" http://historisches-marinearchiv.de/pro ... var2=wert2
AC8549. I think it was not mine but "mine defeder" (sprengboje in german). Too little was damages for mine. Mine was alone - drifting, perhaps.

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#610

Post by lupodimare89 » 09 Oct 2014, 16:03

Thanks again!

Here a little recheking as promised, of Baltic Sea.

Once again, i will try focus on elements or details that have not been searched before, to prevent repetitions.



First of all there are two events (that may be rise interest-replies from our Finnish friends) about winter war.

On 18 January 1940 i've found an interesting description of Finnish armed icebreaker Tarmo having an encounter and opening fire against transport "Kazakstan" and armed icebreaker Jermak close Someri.
For what i've read however this encounter (and other attempts) didn't resulted in a true exchange of fire or some kind of effects.
(Tarmo was however bombed by aircrafts later)



Making a little check on the German translated KTB i've found for day 16 December 1939 a report that German steamer GINNHEIM was "shelled by Russians" when approaching the pilot station northeast Seskaer off Kronstadt
It's known what happened?


Moving forward in summer 1941, i had a little note about the Battle of Bengtskar on 26 July 1941. Because i found this (from Finnish side):
Soviet claims: up to 50 finns killed, 1 enemy watchboat sunk, one gunboat heavy damaged, 2 finnish aircraft shot down. Stated losses - 30 man + MO-238 (not PK).
While it's pretty much clear the loss of PK/MO 238 /306 (we've seen about the name change issue), and while it's clear that the "gunboat heavy damaged" was a soviet overclaim, i'm curious about the "enemy watchboat sunk".
It could be possible that the Finnish side had one of the small motor-cutter we've already seen earlier? (like the one lost in winter war by DD fire, and the one captured in Ladoga Lake)


Another little question more for Finnish users regards the attack on 30 September 1941 against Suursaari harbour by MTBs Nuoli and Sisu. (i don't think we have already discussed about it)
As we saw, apart the old claim of sinking a minesweeper, the only effective result was some minor splinter damages on submarine L-3 that returned fire. On that description however:
. According to Soviet sources, three torpedoes exploded as they hit the bottom of the anchorage at 20-30 meter distance from the sub, causing minor damages to the ship's mine tubes, while the fourth torpedo was crippled by a 45 mm shell fired from L 3 that hit the torpedo's motor section, so it stopped and sank - in order to be raised later by the Soviets. Finnish MTB´s escaped with some splinter damage.
Presence of splinter damages is mentioned in some Finnish KTBs?



Now, moving on the KTB (December 1941), we have....

at first some attempts of evaluations of Soviet losses from evacuation


Two own German losses by mines are:
On 2 December, minesweeper M-529 (i had already seen it listed on own German own field, and here it's further said).


On 4 December, German steamer ERICH FAULBAUM sank after detonation of Warnemuende.
I can say for sure of location sadly, but to me it seems a bit far from the L-3 minefield laid in German waters.


A little detail of fields in Kolber it's a report that say that on 8 December Germans had swept 407 mines of the field, 14 were already exploded or salvaged, 29 were still unaccounted.


On 16 December there is an interesting list of all the losses suffered so far by Germans in Baltic:
"1 sub
4 minelayers (3 on swedish mines)
2 PTboats
5 minesweepers (3 by explosion in Helsinki)
5 aux.mines (3 fishing vessels, 2 luggers)
2 coast patrol vessels
2 submarine chasers
2 minelayers lost while sweeping own german mines off Kolberg
Torpedo depot boat MOSEL lost in the mine field off windau
A number of minelayers and minesweepers were damaged by bomb and mine hits
Cattle ship DELPHIN (255 GRT) sunk in Kiel Bay, hit mine
"

I admit that i've not made a double check of the numbers of minesweepers lost, will do it later.


Very last entry it's
23 december
Steamer EGERAN that sunk on 23 November was the fourth vessel lost in the Memel harbor mine field

from description it appears to be Germans believe it was an own mine.
However it's just another of the many ships lost on mines in that period that i plan to write some generic questions on tsushima.net

Ruotsinsalmi
Member
Posts: 53
Joined: 22 Jan 2011, 19:52

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#611

Post by Ruotsinsalmi » 09 Oct 2014, 18:57

Hi lupodimare89!

I found something for you:

On 18 January from the war diary of icebreaker Tarmo (rough translation):
"08:45 enemy squadron was shot with the rear gun, but the distance was too long". (nothing else)
In finnish books are mentioned, that the lubricant grease of the Vickers guns frosed in cold air and the cannons did not work properly.

Do you know the following page, there are mentioned more than 40.000 shiplosses during WW II, also those, that you were interested: http://www.schiffswrackliste.de/Gesamtv ... 0ts%20.htm

Pekka
Last edited by Ruotsinsalmi on 09 Oct 2014, 21:45, edited 1 time in total.


igorr
Member
Posts: 852
Joined: 29 Aug 2009, 03:21

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#613

Post by igorr » 11 Oct 2014, 17:45

lupodimare89 wrote: Making a little check on the German translated KTB i've found for day 16 December 1939 a report that German steamer GINNHEIM was "shelled by Russians" when approaching the pilot station northeast Seskaer off Kronstadt
It's known what happened?
I have no knowledge about firing at any ships by soviet ship that day. Only activity was gunboat KRASNAYA GORKA whoch fired on land targets.

Two own German losses by mines are:
On 2 December, minesweeper M-529 (i had already seen it listed on own German own field, and here it's further said).
On 4 December, German steamer ERICH FAULBAUM sank after detonation of Warnemuende.
I can say for sure of location sadly, but to me it seems a bit far from the L-3 minefield laid in German waters.
Very last entry it's
23 december
Steamer EGERAN that sunk on 23 November was the fourth vessel lost in the Memel harbor mine field
from description it appears to be Germans believe it was an own mine.
However it's just another of the many ships lost on mines in that period that i plan to write some generic questions on tsushima.net
When germans say that mines was their own, there is no reasons for not trusted them.

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#614

Post by lupodimare89 » 13 Oct 2014, 11:17

Do you know the following page, there are mentioned more than 40.000 shiplosses during WW II, also those, that you were interested: http://www.schiffswrackliste.de/Gesamtv ... 0ts%20.htm
Thanks ^^ i had already seen that site.
It's good for keeping track of lots of things, even if some ones we have already found to be little mistakes here and there

Btw i think it's a pity that Tarmo and Jermak never managed to face each others properly, i've seen also that in 1918 they came close to it, but with no real big event.

Ginnheim:
viewtopic.php?f=59&t=167760&hilit
Thanks! so it was finnish artillery job

I have no knowledge about firing at any ships by soviet ship that day. Only activity was gunboat KRASNAYA GORKA whoch fired on land targets.
It's basically from Finnish site report of Soviet report.
Could have been easily a mistake.
When germans say that mines was their own, there is no reasons for not trusted them.
For M-529 was for sure.
For E.Faulbaum wasn't said of whom, but could have been only not-soviet i think.

For Egeran i had re-checked and town.ural.ru reported them as one of the many losses on own german friendly field.
I'm still think that something left open for L-3 in general, because on the KTB we know for sure that his mines on Memel were not swept (or not all of them at least), considering that one was found an year later by Germans.

lupodimare89
Member
Posts: 594
Joined: 07 Mar 2013, 02:32

Re: Soviet Naval Battles (help with info)

#615

Post by lupodimare89 » 20 Oct 2014, 10:02

Just to say that i'm a bit busy in these days. (university)

Still plans to make some of the checking for uncommon-weird-strange things in Baltic.

AND try to figure some of the minefields effects (from surface ships, especially the ones unseen before) especially in Baltic and Black Sea.

Post Reply

Return to “The Soviet Union at War 1917-1945”