#582
Post
by ljadw » 09 Sep 2021, 22:06
I disagree with Neillands : he neglects the role of morale in war : if the Italians were running away, it would be very possible to go to Tripoli and to capture the city with a few battalions .He also neglects the fact that a strong WDF (if there was no Lustre ) would have much less chance to go to Tripoli (1000 km ) before the arrival of the Germans and before the arrival of the Italian reinforcements .
The truth is that the stronger you are, the slower you can advance : 100 tanks advance faster than 500 tanks,10000 men advance faster than 100000 men .
The Germans had planned an advance to the AA line after the collapse of the Soviets in the Summer of 1941, an advance without the Panzer divisions, because tanks were not made to advance 1000 km,but only for short distances .
It was the same in NA : Montgomery was going to Tripoli with one division,and it took him 2 months .
OÇonnor had not 2 months available to go to Tripoli,only a few weeks,and this presumes a small force which was available .
Both, Lustre and the advance to Tripoli were possible simultaneously .But the capture of Tripoli depended on what the Italians could and would do .