Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

Discussions on books and other reference material on the WW1, Inter-War or WW2 as well as the authors. Hosted by Andy H.
User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#1

Post by Cult Icon » 28 May 2021, 18:11

Hardcover – November 30, 2021
by Arthur W. Gullachsen
South of the Norman city of Caen, the twin features of the Verrières and Bourguebus ridges were key stepping stones for the British Second Army in late July 1944—taking them was crucial if it was to be successful in its attempt to break out of the Normandy bridgehead. To capture this vital ground, Allied forces would have to defeat arguably the strongest German armored formation in Normandy: the I. SS-Panzerkorps “Leibstandarte." The resulting battles of late July and early August 1944 saw powerful German defensive counterattacks south of Caen inflict tremendous casualties, regain lost ground and at times defeat Anglo-Canadian operations in detail.

Viewed by the German leadership as militarily critical, the majority of its armored assets were deployed to dominate this excellent tank country east of the Orne river. These defeats and the experience of meeting an enemy with near-equal resources exposed a flawed Anglo-Canadian offensive tactical doctrine that was overly dependent on the supremacy of its artillery forces. Furthermore, weaknesses in Allied tank technology inhibited their armored forces from fighting a decisive armored battle, forcing Anglo-Canadian infantry and artillery forces to further rely on First World War “Bite and Hold” tactics, massively supported by artillery. Confronted with the full force of the Panzerwaffe, Anglo-Canadian doctrine at times floundered. In response, the Royal Artillery and Royal Canadian Artillery units pummeled the German tankers and grenadiers, but despite their best efforts, ground could not be captured by concentrated artillery fire alone.

This is a detailed account of the success of I. SS-Panzerkorps' defensive operations, aimed at holding the Vèrrieres-Bourgebus ridges in late July 1944.

Table of Contents

Introduction: The Fighting East of the Orne 18–31 July 1944

Chapter 1: The German way of war in Normandy, Summer 1944
Chapter 2: The I. SS-Panzerkorps south of Caen 17 July 1944
Chapter 3: Operation Goodwood: The Attack of the Leibstandarte against the British 8th Corps 18 July 1944
Chapter 4: Operation Atlantic Day 1: The 272. Infantrie Division is pushed back 18 July 1944
Chapter 5: The Leibstandarte and Hitlerjugend hold the line: Days 2 and 3 of Operation Goodwood: 19-20 July 1944
Chapter 6: Atlantic Day 2: The Canadian Infantry Divisions advance 19 July 1944
Chapter 7: Atlantic Day 3: The Leibstandarte and 2. Panzer Division Counterattack, 20 July 1944
Chapter 8: Atlantic Day 4: The Defeat of the 6th Canadian Infantry Brigade 21 July 1944

Conclusion
Bibliography
Appendices
Index
https://www.amazon.com/dp/163624002X/?c ... _lig_dp_it

User avatar
Sheldrake
Member
Posts: 3749
Joined: 28 Apr 2013, 18:14
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#2

Post by Sheldrake » 29 May 2021, 01:33

There looks like an overlap with Ken Tout's Bloody Battle for Tilly
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Bloody-Battle- ... 075093056X
The chapters don't extent to cover all the actions to 31st July e.g. Op Spring 25 July


User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#3

Post by Cult Icon » 29 May 2021, 01:36

Sheldrake wrote:
29 May 2021, 01:33
There looks like an overlap with Ken Tout's Bloody Battle for Tilly
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Bloody-Battle- ... 075093056X
The chapters don't extent to cover all the actions to 31st July e.g. Op Spring 25 July
I find this book to be more of a popular history with a lot of personal accounts. This might be more analytical given the background of the author and his other book, An army of never ending strength.
Last edited by Cult Icon on 29 May 2021, 02:30, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Sheldrake
Member
Posts: 3749
Joined: 28 Apr 2013, 18:14
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#4

Post by Sheldrake » 29 May 2021, 01:45

Sorry but the blurb reads as some of the worst kind of Paul Carelesque puff for the wehrmacht. At an operational level the Germans did not have enough combat power to resist the allies. They did not "defeat" the allies but were sucked into an attritional battle that pinned the German armour against the Anglo Canadians at Caen.

User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#5

Post by Cult Icon » 29 May 2021, 02:40

Sheldrake wrote:
29 May 2021, 01:45
Sorry but the blurb reads as some of the worst kind of Paul Carelesque puff for the wehrmacht. At an operational level the Germans did not have enough combat power to resist the allies. They did not "defeat" the allies but were sucked into an attritional battle that pinned the German armour against the Anglo Canadians at Caen.
This is the oh so very British take on it for sure. I never bought that line that the Field Marshal was the consummate puppet-master as much as the British do, however. Some of it is hedging and clever wording just in-case operations do not generate the maximal results. I give that line 70-80%.

The unsuccessful battles of Verrières Ridge are an interest for the Canadians. However this book covers ATLANTIC but somehow the blurb cuts off. My guess that if the intro continues, it will cover SPRING as well.

This person is also a Canadian officer.

https://www.rmc-cmr.ca/en/history/arthur-gullachsen

"A Second World War specialist, Captain Gullachsen’s areas of expertise include the study of the replacement of equipment and personnel losses as well as German armoured forces during the late war period."

PhD, Canadian Military History, University of Western Ontario. October 2016.
PhD Dissertation title: An Army of Never Ending Strength: The Reinforcement and Re-equipment of the Canadian Army's Combat Arms Regiments in North West Europe 1944-1945.

2003-2005
Master of Arts, Canadian Military History, University of New Brunswick. April 2005.
MA Thesis Title: The Defeat and Attrition of the 12th SS Panzer Division Hitlerjugend, A Case Study: June 6th-July 12th, 1944.

So was this one, who published a book called "Tank tactics' that is rather Germanophile:

https://scholars.wlu.ca/cgi/viewcontent ... ontext=cmh

Does a conspiratorial idea appear that this person, like some American military persons, might be advocating some German ways of war?

Michael Kenny
Member
Posts: 8267
Joined: 07 May 2002, 20:40
Location: Teesside

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#6

Post by Michael Kenny » 29 May 2021, 04:12

Cult Icon wrote:
29 May 2021, 02:40


This person is also a Canadian officer.

https://www.rmc-cmr.ca/en/history/arthur-gullachsen

"A Second World War specialist, Captain Gullachsen’s areas of expertise include the study of the replacement of equipment and personnel losses as well as German armoured forces during the late war period."

PhD, Canadian Military History, University of Western Ontario. October 2016.
PhD Dissertation title: An Army of Never Ending Strength: The Reinforcement and Re-equipment of the Canadian Army's Combat Arms Regiments in North West Europe 1944-1945.

2003-2005
Master of Arts, Canadian Military History, University of New Brunswick. April 2005.
MA Thesis Title: The Defeat and Attrition of the 12th SS Panzer Division Hitlerjugend, A Case Study: June 6th-July 12th, 1944.

It is a sign of your superficial reading/understanding in this area that you missed the fact he has been a member here since 2009

memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=37727

User avatar
Sheldrake
Member
Posts: 3749
Joined: 28 Apr 2013, 18:14
Location: London
Contact:

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#7

Post by Sheldrake » 29 May 2021, 11:10

Cult Icon wrote:
29 May 2021, 02:40
Sheldrake wrote:
29 May 2021, 01:45
Sorry but the blurb reads as some of the worst kind of Paul Carelesque puff for the wehrmacht. At an operational level the Germans did not have enough combat power to resist the allies. They did not "defeat" the allies but were sucked into an attritional battle that pinned the German armour against the Anglo Canadians at Caen.
This is the oh so very British take on it for sure. I never bought that line that the Field Marshal was the consummate puppet-master as much as the British do, however. Some of it is hedging and clever wording just in-case operations do not generate the maximal results. I give that line 70-80%.
monty.jpg
Its is an operational art thing. Its the same reason why Pershing had to press into the Meuse Argonne with half trained troops in September 1918.

The Germans faced a superior enemy on two lines of advance. Their own doctrine required them to pick which they would make their point of main effort. Both allied forces had to press at the same time to avoid the Germans switching forces. The Anglo Canadian army had no choice but to make a maximum effort over the period covered by the book. They faced a resolute enemy armed with longer ranged weapons and heavier tanks defending in depth. The solution that emerged over the period was to use tactical nuke levels of firepower to hit defended localities, followed up by armour and APC mounted infantry. But that wasn't going to help over the period over which the US were going to mount op Cobra.

The suggestion that somehow better tactics would have won the day or the attacks should have been abandoned does a dis-service to the men who fought and fell knowing the tactical disadvantages they faced.
This person is also a Canadian officer.
https://www.rmc-cmr.ca/en/history/arthur-gullachsen

"A Second World War specialist, Captain Gullachsen’s areas of expertise include the study of the replacement of equipment and personnel losses as well as German armoured forces during the late war period."

PhD, Canadian Military History, University of Western Ontario. October 2016.
PhD Dissertation title: An Army of Never Ending Strength: The Reinforcement and Re-equipment of the Canadian Army's Combat Arms Regiments in North West Europe 1944-1945.

2003-2005
Master of Arts, Canadian Military History, University of New Brunswick. April 2005.
MA Thesis Title: The Defeat and Attrition of the 12th SS Panzer Division Hitlerjugend, A Case Study: June 6th-July 12th, 1944.
So was this one, who published a book called "Tank tactics' that is rather Germanophile:
https://scholars.wlu.ca/cgi/viewcontent ... ontext=cmh
Does a conspiratorial idea appear that this person, like some American military persons, might be advocating some German ways of war?
I await the book with bated breath. Maybe the Blurb was written with the idea of appealing to the Wehrboo market ;)

User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#8

Post by Cult Icon » 30 May 2021, 23:20

Sheldrake wrote:
29 May 2021, 11:10
I await the book with bated breath. Maybe the Blurb was written with the idea of appealing to the Wehrboo market ;)

I should refer you to the linked pdf of the other Canadian officer. It hints at denying the puppet-master narrative for SPRING and there is a chapter on SPRING in the Tank Tactics book. Also, the subject of interest of the new author is clearly marked. This is the not the first MA paper that I have seen that's about the 12.SS.

A good way to succeed in life is to create the rules and then place yourself in them...that way the worst you can do in the game is a limited success.. :lol:

Michael Kenny
Member
Posts: 8267
Joined: 07 May 2002, 20:40
Location: Teesside

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#9

Post by Michael Kenny » 31 May 2021, 01:52

Cult Icon wrote:
30 May 2021, 23:20



I should refer you to the linked pdf of the other Canadian officer. It hints at denying the puppet-master narrative for SPRING and there is a chapter on SPRING in the Tank Tactics book. Also, the subject of interest of the new author is clearly marked. This is the not the first MA paper that I have seen that's about the 12.SS.
In his haste to disparage the Allied effort Jarymowycx appears to be confused. Footnote 49:
Screenshot_f141-vertde.jpg
First sPz Abt 503 (pink box) was not 'split up' but rather its 3rd kp was more or less destroyed during GOODWOOD and the crews sent back to re-equip. The Allies destroyed 3kp. Though this Unit (1 & 2 kp) is said to have seen heavy combat its operations and movements in the 4 weeks after GOODWOOD are very vague. They seemed to have not been in any major engagements nor achieved anything of note. For certain they were in some way involved in trying to stop BLUECOAT but facts are very hard to find.

Second sSS Pz Abt 101 (blue box) was never 'west of Mortain. Not at any time. In fact they were used to try and counter BLUECOAT and this poster even mentioned one of their actions earlier:
Cult Icon wrote:
27 May 2021, 14:29
(examples, the Operational reserves deployed in SPRING, the Grimsbosq attack, 12SS village fights early campaign
Third sSS PzAbt 102 (green box)were also never at Mortain'. They too were used to try and halt BLUECOAT (Vire-Vassy) and when that failed they were rushed to Falaise on Aug 9th and were consumed by The Falaise Pocket.

Look at the books used as references if you want to see where Jarymowycx went wrong.

Richard Anderson
Member
Posts: 6400
Joined: 01 Jan 2016, 22:21
Location: Bremerton, Washington

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#10

Post by Richard Anderson » 31 May 2021, 03:41

Michael Kenny wrote:
31 May 2021, 01:52
Look at the books used as references if you want to see where Jarymowycx went wrong.
I dislike bad mouthing the late colonel (he died January 2017), but there are parts of Tank Tactics that are just simply poorly researched. He is one of those who apparently believe the basement of Alexandria High School where the U.S. Army Armored Force had its genesis, was across the Potomac River from D.C. in Virginia.
Richard C. Anderson Jr.

American Thunder: U.S. Army Tank Design, Development, and Doctrine in World War II
Cracking Hitler's Atlantic Wall
Hitler's Last Gamble
Artillery Hell

User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#11

Post by Cult Icon » 31 May 2021, 04:34

Richard Anderson wrote:
31 May 2021, 03:41
I dislike bad mouthing the late colonel (he died January 2017), but there are parts of Tank Tactics that are just simply poorly researched.
Do you disagree with the article/chapter on SPRING?

Not too inconsistent to Fields of Fire (Terry Copp who is trying rehabilitate the Canadians), Agte, Reynolds, and Tieke.

My money is that the new book will be lengthy history of these actions, be pro-German and will disappoint you all. I could be wrong though, not having read anything he published.

User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#12

Post by Cult Icon » 13 Jun 2021, 20:15

Title of the book has changed to something that makes more sense:

"Volume I: Operations Goodwood and Atlantic, July 18–22, 1944"

Presumably, Vol. 2 will finish it.

Michael Kenny
Member
Posts: 8267
Joined: 07 May 2002, 20:40
Location: Teesside

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#13

Post by Michael Kenny » 13 Jun 2021, 20:55

Cult Icon wrote:
13 Jun 2021, 20:15
Title of the book has changed to something that makes more sense:

"Volume I: Operations Goodwood and Atlantic, July 18–22, 1944"

Presumably, Vol. 2 will finish it.
As he has not logged in here since March you might be better off asking him on WW2Talk:

http://ww2talk.com/index.php?threads/or ... ost-932283

It looks like he is still working on it .

Panther Arthur
Member
Posts: 913
Joined: 03 Aug 2009, 23:56

On sale now!! Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August

#14

Post by Panther Arthur » 22 Jan 2022, 19:59

Hello Everyone,

RE: Bloody Verrières Book - on sale now

Its is now out in the continental US (large numbers in the Casemate US warehouse) and shipping soon to other Amazon warehouses and online retailers, as well as Barnes and Noble brick and mortar stores. (Possibly delayed by COVID, ect, in the UK and Canada)

https://www.casematepublishers.com/bloo ... exDnvvMJD8

Thank you for your interest and support

Amazon US site - no # 1 as of 22 Jan 2022 - (Canadian Military History - though it is actually a book about the German Army and Waffen-SS. I don't make up these categories - lol )

https://www.amazon.com/gp/bestsellers/b ... hrsr_books


Some people have written about Verrières Ridge, Bourguebus Ridge, the Goodwood battle and Operation Atlantic -

But believe me - this is the real deal.


All the best, and thank you for your interest and support

Arthur W. Gullachsen
Last edited by Panther Arthur on 22 Jan 2022, 22:04, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Cult Icon
Member
Posts: 4481
Joined: 08 Apr 2014, 20:00

Re: Bloody Verrieres: I.SS Panzerkorps' Defense of the Verrieres-Bourguebus Ridges, Normandy, July-August 1944

#15

Post by Cult Icon » 22 Jan 2022, 20:01

Thanks ... !

When will vol. 2 come out?

Post Reply

Return to “Books & other Reference Material”