I need help for Id. heavy gun
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Thank you for your reply, Terry.
Anyone else for my image of 21 Nov 2011?
On the other hand I have some doubts about this german Minenwerfer:
25cm sMW L3 a/A, 25cm sMW L5 n/A or 17cm mMW L3.8 a/A???
I am often very difficult to distinguish between these models
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
Anyone else for my image of 21 Nov 2011?
On the other hand I have some doubts about this german Minenwerfer:
25cm sMW L3 a/A, 25cm sMW L5 n/A or 17cm mMW L3.8 a/A???
I am often very difficult to distinguish between these models
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
It looks indeed like a camouflaged 9.2 in. railway gun (platform in the back, raised carriage, etc.) but I'm not quite sure about the Mk number.Terry Duncan wrote:Possibly a British 9.2" gun/howitzer. I recall seeing a very similar mounting for those, but cannot lay hands on a photo to check this.
Emmanuel
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Thanks for your reply, Emmanuel
Here a new image from Ebay. I know it is a very difficult question but...... :roll: Any idea?
Thanks in advance
Sturm78
Here a new image from Ebay. I know it is a very difficult question but...... :roll: Any idea?
Thanks in advance
Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
There's something of a French "16 cm Mle 1887" (actual caliber: 164,7 mm) in the barrel. And it looks like some kind of a test setup, maybe balancing.
Emmanuel
Emmanuel
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
It is possible, although it is difficult to ensure.Emmanuel wrote
There's something of a French "16 cm Mle 1887" (actual caliber: 164,7 mm) in the barrel
On the other hand I found this small image on Ebay. Any idea?
Sturm78
- Attachments
-
- barrel trailer-.JPG (109.13 KiB) Viewed 1855 times
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Sturm78,
Guy François thinks that it could be a 25.4 cm Russian gun of Canet design (I was off by almost 10 cm ! ) If you compare with the pictures you posted this year on this same thread, the similarities with the barrels of the Russian 10 inch/254 mm L/45 Obuhov gun are indeed striking :
on February 22nd :
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic. ... 7&start=30
and on September 27th
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic. ... 1#p1645951
Emmanuel
Guy François thinks that it could be a 25.4 cm Russian gun of Canet design (I was off by almost 10 cm ! ) If you compare with the pictures you posted this year on this same thread, the similarities with the barrels of the Russian 10 inch/254 mm L/45 Obuhov gun are indeed striking :
on February 22nd :
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic. ... 7&start=30
and on September 27th
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic. ... 1#p1645951
Emmanuel
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Thank you for your reply, Emmanuel.
Guy François might be right. In any case it is very difficult to identify.
Any idea about my last image?
PD: Why not answer me directly Guy François? :roll:
Regards Sturm78
Guy François might be right. In any case it is very difficult to identify.
Any idea about my last image?
PD: Why not answer me directly Guy François? :roll:
Regards Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Hi all,
I need help with this french gun:
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
I need help with this french gun:
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
I think it's a French naval 16 c Mle 1893 used as heavy artillery.
16 c = 16 cm but the actual caliber was 164,7 mm - The French Navy went back to using cm for the calibers of its guns between 1910 and 1924 but the French Army sticked to the mm.
Emmanuel
16 c = 16 cm but the actual caliber was 164,7 mm - The French Navy went back to using cm for the calibers of its guns between 1910 and 1924 but the French Army sticked to the mm.
Emmanuel
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Thanks for your help, Emmanuel.
Do you have any other image of the 164.7mm Mle 1893 or Mle 1896 for compare?
On the other hand I also need help with this heavy coastal gun. According to photocaption Russian gun
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
Do you have any other image of the 164.7mm Mle 1893 or Mle 1896 for compare?
On the other hand I also need help with this heavy coastal gun. According to photocaption Russian gun
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Sturm78,
You'll find a picture of a 16 cm (164,7 mm) Mle 1893 in this thread:
http://pages14-18.mesdiscussions.net/pa ... _836_1.htm
Regarding your last Russian gun, it looks again like a 254 mm L/45 Obuhov.
Emmanuel
You'll find a picture of a 16 cm (164,7 mm) Mle 1893 in this thread:
http://pages14-18.mesdiscussions.net/pa ... _836_1.htm
Regarding your last Russian gun, it looks again like a 254 mm L/45 Obuhov.
Emmanuel
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Thank you for your reply, Emmanuel.
About the Russian gun the barrel seems longer than the gun of your image of 12 Nov.
On the other hand, Can anyone identify this gun?
I think Russian 107mm M1910 but I am not sure
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
About the Russian gun the barrel seems longer than the gun of your image of 12 Nov.
On the other hand, Can anyone identify this gun?
I think Russian 107mm M1910 but I am not sure
Image from Ebay
Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Sturm78,
For the 254 mm gun, it is hard to tell if the barrel was actually longer or not than on the other picture. However, there was a longer 254 mm gun than the L/45, the L/50 Pattern 1908, but I don't think that it was used by the Russians as heavy artillery.
I agree with you for the 107 mm gun M1910: the breach greatly ressembles the breach of the French 105 mm L Mle 1913.
Emmanuel
For the 254 mm gun, it is hard to tell if the barrel was actually longer or not than on the other picture. However, there was a longer 254 mm gun than the L/45, the L/50 Pattern 1908, but I don't think that it was used by the Russians as heavy artillery.
I agree with you for the 107 mm gun M1910: the breach greatly ressembles the breach of the French 105 mm L Mle 1913.
Emmanuel
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
I think it is a 14cm (138,6mm) Mle1910 de marine or maybe a Mle 1887,1891 or 1893Emmanuel wrote
I think it's a French naval 16 c Mle 1893 used as heavy artillery.
Sturm78
Re: I need help for Id. heavy gun
Hi all,
Two images from Ebay:
Image 1: 75mm Schneider PD.15 gun, according to photocaption. Was this rare gun used by any country or only prototype?
Image 2: I think 8cm M05/08 austrio-hungarian gun but I am not sure
Sturm78
Two images from Ebay:
Image 1: 75mm Schneider PD.15 gun, according to photocaption. Was this rare gun used by any country or only prototype?
Image 2: I think 8cm M05/08 austrio-hungarian gun but I am not sure
Sturm78