Spanish mortars
Re: Spanish mortars
Hi all,
Looking at the 120mm Franco M1939 and 120mm ECIA-Valero mortars, I think they are very similar in his general configuration.
In addition, the Franco mortar was manufactured by Esperanza y Cia in Marquina, ie, in the same factory where the mortar 120mm ECIA-Valero will be manufactured later
Then my question is: is the mortar 120mm ECIA-Valero a development of mortar Franco ??
Was the mortar Franco manufactured in serie ??
When the 120mm ECIA-Valero mortar entered in service with Spanish Army ??
Any aditional information and/or image will be wellcome...
Regards Sturm78
Looking at the 120mm Franco M1939 and 120mm ECIA-Valero mortars, I think they are very similar in his general configuration.
In addition, the Franco mortar was manufactured by Esperanza y Cia in Marquina, ie, in the same factory where the mortar 120mm ECIA-Valero will be manufactured later
Then my question is: is the mortar 120mm ECIA-Valero a development of mortar Franco ??
Was the mortar Franco manufactured in serie ??
When the 120mm ECIA-Valero mortar entered in service with Spanish Army ??
Any aditional information and/or image will be wellcome...
Regards Sturm78
- Ironmachine
- Member
- Posts: 5821
- Joined: 07 Jul 2005, 11:50
- Location: Spain
Re: Spanish mortars
Yes, the 120mm "Franco" mortar was produced in series. The article about the "Franco" mortar employment by the Blue Division that I mentioned earlier in this thread states that the number of such mortars produced given by different sources is usually 48, but the authors of the articles had found a document in the Archivo General Militar that shows the Spanish Army had 71 "Franco mortars" in 1963.Sturm78 wrote:Was the mortar Franco manufactured in serie ??
Re: Spanish mortars
Thank you, Ironmachine
Sturm78
Sturm78
- Ironmachine
- Member
- Posts: 5821
- Joined: 07 Jul 2005, 11:50
- Location: Spain
Re: Spanish mortars
If you are interested in the "Franco" mortar, that article is a very valuable source, much more so as there seems to be very little information available. It has a number of photographs of the mortars both in Russia and in Spain, plus good information about the mortar's story. Despite its title, the information provided is in no way limited to the mortar's service with the Blue Division.
Re: Spanish mortars
Do you have this article in pdf format ?? I would be very grateful ...Ironmachine wrote
If you are interested in the "Franco" mortar, that article is a very valuable source, much more so as there seems to be very little information available. It has a number of photographs of the mortars both in Russia and in Spain, plus good information about the mortar's story. Despite its title, the information provided is in no way limited to the mortar's service with the Blue Division.
Regards Sturm78
- Ironmachine
- Member
- Posts: 5821
- Joined: 07 Jul 2005, 11:50
- Location: Spain
Re: Spanish mortars
No, but the magazine is still available through the editor's website:
http://www.afeditores.com/product.php?id_product=144
http://www.afeditores.com/product.php?id_product=144
Re: Spanish mortars
Thank you, Ironmachine
Sturm78
Sturm78
Re: Spanish mortars
Hi Ironmachine and all,
I got the magazine but is rather disappointing....
On the one hand, the article just diverted to personal achievements of one of the members of the Blue Division that handled these mortars and secondly the pictures, but a couple of them, are of very poor quality.
Beyond that, the article includes two different tables with the main technical characteristics of the mortar but with conflicting data: In one of them, it is given a total weight of 691kg and in the other of 848Kg. In one it is given a maximum range of 7000m and the 6400m in the another one...
Finally both in this article as in the scans of Carnet Instructor - Descripcion del mortero Franco de 120mm y su granada, posted by Ironmachine here on 26 Oct 2011, is given a barrel length of 2m but when studying the images is evident a length of tube much greater, of around 3m, unless servants were dwarfs....
Sturm78
I got the magazine but is rather disappointing....
On the one hand, the article just diverted to personal achievements of one of the members of the Blue Division that handled these mortars and secondly the pictures, but a couple of them, are of very poor quality.
Beyond that, the article includes two different tables with the main technical characteristics of the mortar but with conflicting data: In one of them, it is given a total weight of 691kg and in the other of 848Kg. In one it is given a maximum range of 7000m and the 6400m in the another one...
Finally both in this article as in the scans of Carnet Instructor - Descripcion del mortero Franco de 120mm y su granada, posted by Ironmachine here on 26 Oct 2011, is given a barrel length of 2m but when studying the images is evident a length of tube much greater, of around 3m, unless servants were dwarfs....
Sturm78
-
- Member
- Posts: 1403
- Joined: 26 May 2007, 16:22
- Location: USA
Re: Spanish mortars
I would not agree with the logic of doubting the length of 0f Three meters. I lived in Spain during the mid 1960s and I found that the average Spanish male of the period was about 5 feet tall. At 5feet 11 inches I looked like a giant in downtown Madrid. Because of this the barrel length of 3 meters would be about right if you assume the gunners are no more than 5 feet in height.
- Ironmachine
- Member
- Posts: 5821
- Joined: 07 Jul 2005, 11:50
- Location: Spain
Re: Spanish mortars
Well, not for me.Sturm78 wrote:I got the magazine but is rather disappointing....
Yes, the article digress about the Blue División and Fernández Medrano, but still it has more information about the "Franco" mortars than any other source I have seen. And yes, the pictures are of por quality, but again they are valuable because the amount of graphic information about those mortars available is rather limited. However, this is just a matter of taste and taste is so personal, that's why I usually don't recommend books and the like...Sturm78 wrote:On the one hand, the article just diverted to personal achievements of one of the members of the Blue Division that handled these mortars and secondly the pictures, but a couple of them, are of very poor quality.
There is no conflicting data really. If you read the article carefully, you will note that the first table is for the first mortars produced (that can be considered prototypes), and the latter one is for the mortars in service in 1942, after a number of modifications.Sturm78 wrote:Beyond that, the article includes two different tables with the main technical characteristics of the mortar but with conflicting data: In one of them, it is given a total weight of 691kg and in the other of 848Kg. In one it is given a maximum range of 7000m and the 6400m in the another one...
That's probably because you are not considering that not all the barrel is barrel. In other words, the barrel length is for the barrel, not including the "culata": The part marked in red is the barrel, the part marked in blue is the "culata".Sturm78 wrote:Finally both in this article as in the scans of Carnet Instructor - Descripcion del mortero Franco de 120mm y su granada, posted by Ironmachine here on 26 Oct 2011, is given a barrel length of 2m but when studying the images is evident a length of tube much greater, of around 3m, unless servants were dwarfs....
Re: Spanish mortars
Ummmhhh....The amendments relating to the suspension and reinforcement of several pieces added to the mortar.....150kg of weight !! ....and reduced the range in 600m !!Ironmachine wrote
There is no conflicting data really. If you read the article carefully, you will note that the first table is for the first mortars produced (that can be considered prototypes), and the latter one is for the mortars in service in 1942, after a number of modifications.
Thank you very much for the clarification..... I guess the "culata" housed the brake and recovery mechanisms, no ?? . Anyway, the total lenght of the barrel + "culata" would be around 3m more or less...Ironmachine wrote
That's probably because you are not considering that not all the barrel is barrel. In other words, the barrel length is for the barrel, not including the "culata":
Regards Sturm78
- Ironmachine
- Member
- Posts: 5821
- Joined: 07 Jul 2005, 11:50
- Location: Spain
Re: Spanish mortars
IIRC, in the article there is also a mention about modifying the fins of the projectile. This could have changed the ballistics and reduced the range. There could have been other changes, like a reduction of the propelling charge or an increase in weight of the projectile...Sturm78 wrote:Ummmhhh....The amendments relating to the suspension and reinforcement of several pieces added to the mortar.....150kg of weight !! ....and reduced the range in 600m !! 8
Yes.Sturm78 wrote:I guess the "culata" housed the brake and recovery mechanisms, no ??
Somewhat less than 3m. There is an schematic drawing at the end of the Carnet del Instructor; working from the only measurement that is shown in the drawing, I would say that a length of 2 meters is right for the barrel and the "culata" has a length of about 0.7-0.75 meters including the "ball" that goes into the baseplate.Sturm78 wrote:Anyway, the total lenght of the barrel + "culata" would be around 3m more or less...
Re: Spanish mortars
Thanks, again, Ironmachine
I suppose the 120mm Ecia-Valero M1942 is the succesor model of this one, is it not ??
Any "wartime" image of this model ??
Sturm78
I suppose the 120mm Ecia-Valero M1942 is the succesor model of this one, is it not ??
Any "wartime" image of this model ??
Sturm78