Which country?

Discussions on all aspects of the smaller Axis nations in Europe and Asia. Hosted by G. Trifkovic.
Octavianus
Member
Posts: 284
Joined: 01 May 2002, 00:23
Location: Europe

Poles with arms Arms

#16

Post by Octavianus » 10 Jul 2002, 15:48

Servus Antti,

The photo was most likely taken in the process of carrying their weapons down. Don't know if you ever seen or heard the stories of the veterans, but it was often that after the soldiers were captured, they were formed in a column, marching until at the end of the column they all hand over their weapons or throw it on a ground. I have seen such photos of Belgian, Yugoslav and Polish soldiers, and even German soldiers surrendering their weapons to the Yugoslav partisans, so such photo was not a suprise with me.

In addition, maybe the photo was erven taken at Westerplatte, where Germans honoured the brave Polish defenders...

In anyway, I still stick with my theory that they are Polish soldiers. They are certainly not Finns, Hungarians, Romanians, Croats, Italians, Belgian, French, British, Soviet, American and not even Czech or Slovakian. Bulgarians used a different type of helmet, the German M1935 helmet, later replaced with M1916. The Slovakian had a different types of unioforms and they used old Czech helment which contsruction is a bit different from the one we are seeing on this photo.
Compare the helmet on a photo with any other photos of Polish soldiers you have and you shall see. I have did this with one of mine photos, and the white buttons and type of helment fit perfectly.

Gratia,

Octavianus

User avatar
Geppistoly Katona
Member
Posts: 225
Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 04:34
Location: Hungary

#17

Post by Geppistoly Katona » 10 Jul 2002, 16:34

The scraggly Rumanian comment was my comment, I DIDNT LITERALLY MEAN THAT, I was just jokingly jesting at ya victor :D


But another reason Pic #1 HAS TO BE YUGOSLAVS, SLOVAKS, CROATS, OR BULGARIANS is look at the top of their guns, the shiny metal and light would is not of German origin, THEY ARE YUGOSLAVIAN Kar 98 Short Mausers!!!!!


And to my knowledge EVEN THE SCRAGGLY RUMANIANS DIDNT SINK LOW ENOUGH TO CARRY A YUGOSLAV MADE RIFLE!!!!
Ismétlopuska ember-Ferfi


User avatar
Geppistoly Katona
Member
Posts: 225
Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 04:34
Location: Hungary

#18

Post by Geppistoly Katona » 10 Jul 2002, 16:36

And if you look closely at the dark tipped gun in the metal I believe it to be an Italian Mannlicher Carcano short rifle of some sort, Italian or a rearsenalled Austro-Hungarian piece?
Ismétlopuska ember-Ferfi

User avatar
Geppistoly Katona
Member
Posts: 225
Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 04:34
Location: Hungary

#19

Post by Geppistoly Katona » 10 Jul 2002, 16:37

But if they were Slovaks wouldnt they have that Eastern Orthodox cross on their helmet fronts?
Ismétlopuska ember-Ferfi

User avatar
Marcus
Member
Posts: 33963
Joined: 08 Mar 2002, 23:35
Location: Europe
Contact:

#20

Post by Marcus » 10 Jul 2002, 18:00

Here is a closeup.
Attachments
german and maybe romanian troops.jpg
Closeup
german and maybe romanian troops.jpg (54.07 KiB) Viewed 2344 times

Reigo
Member
Posts: 671
Joined: 04 Jun 2002, 11:20
Location: Estonia

#21

Post by Reigo » 10 Jul 2002, 18:02

After browsing this site - http://www.bolas.prv.pl/ - it seems to me also that the soldiers on picture 1 are probably Polish.

User avatar
Geppistoly Katona
Member
Posts: 225
Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 04:34
Location: Hungary

#22

Post by Geppistoly Katona » 10 Jul 2002, 18:06

Some of those almost look like Bulgarian Police Mannlicher m 1895 or 93 [ notice one gun with a straight pull bolt] ???? Must be some kind of rag tag army, their weapons are all mixed!!!!
Ismétlopuska ember-Ferfi

User avatar
Geppistoly Katona
Member
Posts: 225
Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 04:34
Location: Hungary

#23

Post by Geppistoly Katona » 10 Jul 2002, 18:07

One even looks like it could be a Belgian 1898 Mauser Hoppy???? What army bought those after WWII that might be your answer....
Ismétlopuska ember-Ferfi

Tapani K.
Member
Posts: 871
Joined: 09 Jul 2002, 12:29
Location: Helsinki, Finland

polish?

#24

Post by Tapani K. » 10 Jul 2002, 18:50

If memory serves me right, Poland manufactured a version of Mauser and the Polish army used it extensively. Also, The helmets seems to be quite like the polish wz.31 helmet. Therefore I, too, would be inclined to vote "Poland" here.

In the other picture, I think the taller Finnish soldier might be wearing the collar tabs of a sotilasvirkamies (military official or something like that in English). This would fit in quite nicely with the idea of there being a Finnish liaison officer and his interpreter photographed withe their German comrades-in-arms.


regards,
Tapani K.

User avatar
Geppistoly Katona
Member
Posts: 225
Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 04:34
Location: Hungary

#25

Post by Geppistoly Katona » 10 Jul 2002, 20:25

Yes the polish did make a few different models of that particular mauser, hower all of them had a blued or patina coated metal, these guns in the picture by the silver glint you see must have been manufactured in the Bulkans or Turkey because they have a poor finish....
Ismétlopuska ember-Ferfi

Kapitan Drago
Member
Posts: 57
Joined: 04 May 2002, 22:59
Location: chicago
Contact:

#26

Post by Kapitan Drago » 12 Jul 2002, 00:16

The walking soldiers looks like Chechoslovacks.
My web page ,with info about Bulgarian military history:
http://hometown.aol.com/bogdanovaslava/index.html

Tapani K.
Member
Posts: 871
Joined: 09 Jul 2002, 12:29
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Czechoslovaks?

#27

Post by Tapani K. » 12 Jul 2002, 15:46

It seems to me that the helmets of the walking soldiers are definitely of the Polish type. The Polish helmet is somewhat similar to the Czech one, but the Polish one is deeper and covers more of the face wheras the Czech helmets is more compact in appearance. Sorry for the unprofessional sounding terms while describing the helmets, but hey, that is what I am: no professional 8-).

regards,
Tapani K.

User avatar
Stéphane
Member
Posts: 26
Joined: 20 Jul 2002, 06:36
Location: Canada

#28

Post by Stéphane » 20 Jul 2002, 23:51

Hi, there. First post.
Must agree with Octavianus. The soldiers in picture #1 are Polish. Was looking at a magazine on the Polish Campaign and there was a picture of unarmed Poles being marched into captivity. In the picture that I have, they all have the same shinny buttons, as well as tunics with 2 breast pockets and tunics without them. Just like pic #1. In picture #1 you can see a soldier wearing the traditional Polish cap (don't know what its called). As well in pic #1 why would there be armed Germans escorting there allies? Can only mean one thing, that they're prisoners being marched off to drop off there weapons and into POW camps, thats why they look dejected and demoralized.

User avatar
Benoit Douville
Member
Posts: 3184
Joined: 11 Mar 2002, 02:13
Location: Montréal

#29

Post by Benoit Douville » 21 Jul 2002, 00:32

Hi and Welcome to the forum. Another Canadian here :)

User avatar
Andy H
Forum Staff
Posts: 15326
Joined: 12 Mar 2002, 21:51
Location: UK and USA

#30

Post by Andy H » 21 Jul 2002, 10:32

How about them being from a Latvian Defence Btn?. The reason's being that they were issued with M1933 Czech Army helmet and Mosin-Nagant's and I suppose that there general look is one that you could associate with that type of unit.

Post Reply

Return to “Minor Axis Nations”