Poland 1939: KIA German officers

Discussions on the personalities of the Wehrmacht and of the organizations not covered in the other sections. Hosted by askropp and Frech.
Post Reply
Piotr Kapuscinski
Host - Allied sections
Posts: 3724
Joined: 12 Jul 2006, 20:17
Location: Poland
Contact:

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#376

Post by Piotr Kapuscinski » 01 Mar 2009, 02:08

Kavallerie Regiment 5 was definitely not attached to 207 ID or GAK I. The same applies to Gruppe Medem.

No - I'm not sure since I have not yet researched OdeB of Eberhard's Group so I might be (and probably are) wrong...
As far as I know Brigade Eberhardt consisted only of Landespolizei-Regiment 1. and Landespolizei-Regiment 2. + one artillery battalion.
And what about SS Heimwehr-Danzig? According to Rolf Michaelis it lost 39 KIA while fighting against LOW, but it also lost 5 to 10 KIA while fighting in Gdansk against Westerplatte (I have got names of 5 of them). Were there any officers among them?
SS Heimwehr-Danzig was also not attached to Brigade Eberhardt (maybe except one - 13. - company, and only temporarily).

Jan-Hendrik
Member
Posts: 8711
Joined: 11 Nov 2004, 13:53
Location: Hohnhorst / Deutschland

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#377

Post by Jan-Hendrik » 01 Mar 2009, 09:32

Kavallerie Regiment 5 was definitely not attached to 207 ID or GAK I.
Impossible as the unit did not have existed anymore on 1st September 1939.

Jan-Hendrik


User avatar
Stauffenberg II
Member
Posts: 3295
Joined: 03 Jan 2003, 18:43
Location: Austria

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#378

Post by Stauffenberg II » 01 Mar 2009, 10:49

Jan-Hendrik,

the list of IIa, H. Gru. Nord is listing von Bandemer as Rittm. d. R. and unit: AA 207.

Jürgen

Jan-Hendrik
Member
Posts: 8711
Joined: 11 Nov 2004, 13:53
Location: Hohnhorst / Deutschland

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#379

Post by Jan-Hendrik » 01 Mar 2009, 11:00

Sorrowly no Stellenbesetzungen for AA 207 and IV./AR 207 for 1939 in the divisional history :cry:

Jan-Hendrik

User avatar
Stauffenberg II
Member
Posts: 3295
Joined: 03 Jan 2003, 18:43
Location: Austria

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#380

Post by Stauffenberg II » 01 Mar 2009, 12:07

I could identify one further officer of the H. Gru. Nord list ... again a minor name difference. Please replace the Schmarbach entry by the following:

Schmarbach (gem. VB Schnarbach) Viktor, 12.05.1917, Lt., A. A. 1, -, 03.09.1939 (Melno), VB, H. Gru. Nord

Please by any chance also add the 2 new guys from Njorl and one by me:

Dr. Breitenstein Alfred Viktor Oskar, 02.09.1894, Ob. St. Vet., -, -, 11.09.1939 (Lowicz), VB
Sölla Hans, 14.10.1918, Lt., -, -, 25.09.1939 (Warschau-Racowice), VB
Tacke Herbert August Otto, 11.03.1919, Lt., -, -, 17.09.1939 (Brochow), VB

User avatar
Bernd R
Member
Posts: 4637
Joined: 01 Feb 2006, 16:12
Location: Bavaria, Germany

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#381

Post by Bernd R » 01 Mar 2009, 12:40

The master list is updated per the edit by Stauffenberg II from 28 Feb, 10:51 and the latest (post above). 8 new - 2 added to the research section : Bachstel, Grczeszecyk - new total : 724 / + 15 .

Jürgen, thanks, great pleasure and very interesting to contribute this way also to this common attempt for a reference list. What a good job by all ! 8-)

Best regards
Bernd

User avatar
Bernd R
Member
Posts: 4637
Joined: 01 Feb 2006, 16:12
Location: Bavaria, Germany

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#382

Post by Bernd R » 01 Mar 2009, 12:53

Keeping track on remarks/statements about officers that might be still missed and summarizing some notes in my files on units with a higher number of casualties let me just throw in a preliminary spot. Re-start and/or start and reminder to go on with further steps there or to state the units done.

50. ID : possibly one of 9 in total not yet listed
GR 42 (1) ??
Brigade Eberhardt (4) / (3) ??
I.R. 6 : 5 Kp.Chefs KIA
I.R. 15 : 1 Offz KIA
I.R. 7 : higher number of casualties
III./I.R. 48 : attached to 207. ID (?) , and high casualties (?)
Pz.Rgt. 7 : high casualties , (29 in total, Offz how many ?)

/ Bernd

Piotr Kapuscinski
Host - Allied sections
Posts: 3724
Joined: 12 Jul 2006, 20:17
Location: Poland
Contact:

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#383

Post by Piotr Kapuscinski » 01 Mar 2009, 13:00

Brigade Eberhardt (4) / (3) ??
We don't have any officer from Brigade Eberhardt listed. Henningsen was from Kriegsmarine ground forces (so we have got one officer from Kriegsmarine listed), not from Brigade Eberhardt.

Btw - if it comes to German officer casualties on the coast - also Panzerzug 3. lost at least 1 officer, as we have got him listed.
Pz.Rgt. 7 : high casualties , (29 in total, Offz how many ?)
Bernd, I. Abteilung of Panzer-Regiment 7. had got 29 KIA according to Lexikon der Wehrmacht, not the whole regiment:

On 01.09.1939:
Die I. Abteilung hatte bei dem Angriff 1 Offizier, 3 Unteroffiziere und 11 Mannschaften als Gefallene und 1 Offizier, 4 Unteroffiziere und 14 Mannschaften als Verwundete zu beklagen.
I. Abteilung lost 39 knocked out tanks on 01.09.1939.

II. Abteilung lost 33 knocked out tanks on 01.09.1939 (so men casualties were probably a bit lower or similar).
Bei der I. Abteilung sind in diesem Feldzug 29 Offiziere, Unteroffiziere und Mannschaften gefallen.
We have got the following KIA officers from Pz.Rgt.7 listed yet:

From I. Abteilung:

Hauptmann Walther (on 01.09.1939)
Leutnant Baumeister
Leutnant von Schlieben

From II. Abteilung:

Leutnant Letz
Leutnant Parow

Have I missed someone?

-----------------------

I have just seen that we have got a mistake in Master List:
Baumeister Alfred, 14.05.1917, Lt., [Zgf. i. d. d. 3. Kp./]Pz. R. 7, Pz. Div. Kempf, 01.09.1939, VB, H. Gru. Nord
According to Lexikon der Wehrmacht only one officer of I. Abteilung was KIA on 01.09.1939 - Hauptmann Walther.

Leutnant Baumeister was KIA bei Różan according to LdW (so either on 05.09.1939 or on 06.09.1939).
Letz Benno, 13.11.1914, Lt., Pz. R. 7, [Pz. Div. Kempf], 01.09.1939, VB, H. Gru. Nord
According to LdW he was Zugführer in 6. Kompanie (II. Abteilung).
I.R. 15 : 1 Offz KIA
Wrong again:
Am 8. September 1939 erlitten die 9. und 10. Kompanie bei einem Waldkampf folgende Verluste:
gefallen:

1 Offizier, [...]
Only these two companies lost one officer gefallen only on 08.09.1939.

Not the whole regiment during the whole campaign...
Last edited by Piotr Kapuscinski on 01 Mar 2009, 14:56, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
Bernd R
Member
Posts: 4637
Joined: 01 Feb 2006, 16:12
Location: Bavaria, Germany

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#384

Post by Bernd R » 01 Mar 2009, 14:51

Hi Peter,

ah, OK, thanks. So more clear for Pz.Rgt. 7 and IR 15 now. Sorry, if irritating or you might say wrong. I did a "tour de force" and noticed this or that, wrote it on my files. When saying let me just throw in a preliminary spot this means no final results or secure facts, just brainstorming. Suggestions for the edit which are a draft for only copy and paste / and layout work for Jürgen sounds different. :wink:

I suggest this details could be added ; on base of the VB entry, per
http://www.lexikon-der-wehrmacht.de/Gli ... iBat30.htm , surely taken from the
Die Geschichte der 30. Infanterie-Division 1939 - 1945 - Hans Breithaupt, Podzun, Bad Nauheim 1955
Tiedemann Wolf-Günter, 04.09.1909, Hptm., -, -, 07.09.1939, VB
Chef 6./I.R. 6, 30. I.D.
Lübbe Daniel Otto Jürgen, 26.11.1910, Oblt., -, -, 10.09.1939, VB
9. or 10. Kp. ; I.R. 6 , 30. I.D.

Bernd

Piotr Kapuscinski
Host - Allied sections
Posts: 3724
Joined: 12 Jul 2006, 20:17
Location: Poland
Contact:

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#385

Post by Piotr Kapuscinski » 01 Mar 2009, 14:57

Hi Bernd,
Bernd R wrote:Sorry, if irritating or you might say wrong. I did a "tour de force" and noticed this or that, wrote it on my files.
Ok, I understand ;).

Btw:

Officers from 21. Infanterie-Division listed yet / casualties of this division (according to the history of this division):

Battle of Grudziądz (1st - 3rd of September 1939):

Tegtmeyer, -, Lt., A. A. 21, 21. Div., -, H. Gru. Nord
Bitschkowski Eberhard, 12.10.1916, Lt., I. R. 45, 21. Div., 02.09.1939, VB, H. Gru. Nord

Code: Select all

Unit					Officers					   Privates and NCO's
					  KIA	WIA	  MIA			KIA	   WIA	 MIA
IR. 3				-		6		  -			 39	   106		 4
IR 24			   -		1		   -			   42	   130		 7
IR 45			   1	   10		  -			   30	   110		 2
PzAbwA 21		-		 -		 -				1		 1		   -
AR 21			   -		 2		 -				2		30		  -
I/AR 57			-		 1		 -				 -		-			- 
AA 21			   1		-		  -			  15		26		  4
Pi 21				-		 2		 -				 -		1		   -
NA 21			   -		 2		 -				 -		2		   - 
Krad-Meldzg 21  -		-		 -				 1		 -		   - 
Together			2		24		-		   130(27)  406(61)   17
Battle of Nowogród at the river Narew:

Wolfram Hans-Dieter, 03.10.1915, Oblt., I. R. 3, 21. Div., 09.09.1939, VB
Schoenborn (od. gem. H. Gru. Nord Schönbörn) Wolfgang, 15.06.1916, Oblt., Pi. Btl. 21, 21. Div., 09.09.1939, VB, H. Gru. Nord
Wiebe Karl-Heinz, 14.07.1917, Lt., I. R. 45, 21. Div., 10.09.1939, VB

Code: Select all

Unit			Officers								  Privates and NCO's
					 KIA	 WIA	 MIA			  KIA		 WIA		 MIA
IR. 3				1		1		 -				 27		   61			 3
IR 24			   -		-		   -				15			26			 -
IR 45			   1	   1		  -				 41			82			 2
AR 21			  -		 3		 -				  1			17			  -
AA 21			   -		-		  -				  2			 5			  2
Pi 21				1		-		 -				 10			12			 -
Together		  3		5		 -				96(16)   203(25)		 7
In combats after 12.09.1939:

Code: Select all

		  
						  KIA	  WIA	MIA			   KIA	WIA	 MIA
21. Infanterie-Division	-		 -	   -			15		 47		 7
But we also have got one more KIA officer from this division (from Infanterie-Regiment 3.):

Gichtmeyer, -, Lt. d. R., I. R. 3, 21. Div., -, H. Gru. Nord

It clearly shows that casualties of the division were in fact higher than according to the divisional history.

Cheers!

Domen
Last edited by Piotr Kapuscinski on 01 Mar 2009, 22:21, edited 4 times in total.

User avatar
Stauffenberg II
Member
Posts: 3295
Joined: 03 Jan 2003, 18:43
Location: Austria

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#386

Post by Stauffenberg II » 01 Mar 2009, 15:03

Bernd R wrote:Hi Peter,

[...]

I suggest this details could be added ; on base of the VB entry, per
http://www.lexikon-der-wehrmacht.de/Gli ... iBat30.htm , surely taken from the
Die Geschichte der 30. Infanterie-Division 1939 - 1945 - Hans Breithaupt, Podzun, Bad Nauheim 1955
Tiedemann Wolf-Günter, 04.09.1909, Hptm., -, -, 07.09.1939, VB
Chef 6./I.R. 6, 30. I.D.
Lübbe Daniel Otto Jürgen, 26.11.1910, Oblt., -, -, 10.09.1939, VB
9. or 10. Kp. ; I.R. 6 , 30. I.D.

Bernd
The figure 5 as regards I. R. 6 appears to be quite proper. We already have listed 4 officers by name in our master list whose family names also appear in the Stellenbesetzung 1938 as per as 03. Jan. 1939:

Hptm. Tiedemann, Kdr. 5. Kp.
Lt. Rohland, Kdr. 8. (MG) Kp.
Lt. Lübbe, RSt
Lt. Sommer, Zgf. i. d. 5. Kp.

User avatar
Marcus
Member
Posts: 33963
Joined: 08 Mar 2002, 23:35
Location: Europe
Contact:

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#387

Post by Marcus » 01 Mar 2009, 15:58

An interesting discussion was split off into a new thread (Volksdeutsche in the Polish army) to not drag this thread off track.

/Marcus

Piotr Kapuscinski
Host - Allied sections
Posts: 3724
Joined: 12 Jul 2006, 20:17
Location: Poland
Contact:

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#388

Post by Piotr Kapuscinski » 01 Mar 2009, 16:31

I.R. 6 : 5 Kp.Chefs KIA
The figure 5 as regards I. R. 6 appears to be quite proper. We already have listed 4 officers by name in our master list whose family names also appear in the Stellenbesetzung 1938 as per as 03. Jan. 1939:

Hptm. Tiedemann, Kdr. 5. Kp.
Lt. Rohland, Kdr. 8. (MG) Kp.
Lt. Lübbe, RSt
Lt. Sommer, Zgf. i. d. 5. Kp.
Infanterie-Regiment 6. lost at least 8 KIA officers:

Image

To this we must add also MIA officers, MIA and never found (so de facto KIA) losses of 30. Infanterie-Division were very heavy. I don't know why the tabel above does not include them.

According to official German figures 30. Infanterie-Division lost at least 117 never found MIA soldiers & officers.

But according to German historian - Bethell (former officer of the division) - the division lost at least 500 soldiers MIA and never found.

Bethell claims that they were murdered in Polish captivity.

-------------------------------------------------------------

And here is the casualty list of I./Infanterie-Regiment 73. (19. Infanterie-Division) during its major combats. I was mentioning this casualty list several times before:

Kampf im Wald von Osuchow 11.09.1939:

http://img124.imageshack.us/img124/2965/straty1wh1.png

Kampf um Lubiejew 16.09.1939:

http://img222.imageshack.us/img222/2214/straty2hf0.png

Kampf bei Dwor Ruszki 18.09.1939:

http://img222.imageshack.us/img222/4924/straty3fw4.png

Kampf um Warschau 27.09.1939:

http://img393.imageshack.us/img393/2982/straty4an9.png

+ some more names of KIA and WIA from this battalion:

Btl.Kdr.: Oberstlt.Hoehne (gef. 1.Sept. durch Artillerie bei Napoleon)

1.Kompanie:

Fw.Leonhard (verw.18.9., verst.i.Laz. am 22.9.39 (Stab))
Hptm.v.Schmeling (am 18.9.1939 kurz nach 4 Uhr gefallen)
Gfr.Dittmar (verw. 5.Sept.)

2.Kompanie:

Schtz.Knoop (Bursche von Chill; Gef. 11.9.39 bei Ostruchow)
Uffz.Andrä (Kp.Truppführer) (verw. 11.9.39 bei Ostruchow)
Schtz.Küker (gef. 5.9. durch Artillerie an der Rakowka)

3.Kompanie:

Lt.d.R.Temme (Zugführer) (gefallen 18.9. bei D.Ruszki)
Gfr.Kruse (verwundet am 14.Sept.39, verstorben an der Verwundung)
Schtz.Bagusch (verwundet am 14.9.39)

4.Kompanie:

Ofw.Schubert (Zghfr.II.Zug), (gefallen durch Artillerietreffer 27.9.1939)
Fw.Kettler (Bauchschuß am 27.9., verstirbt auf dem Weg ins Lazarett)

Gesamtverluste I./73 Polenfeldzug:

http://img222.imageshack.us/img222/4923/straty5xg1.png

Unfortunately MIA are not included.

-----------------------

PS:

We do not have Leutnant d. Reserve Temme (KIA Kampf bei Dwor Ruszki 18.09.1939) listed yet.

User avatar
Bernd R
Member
Posts: 4637
Joined: 01 Feb 2006, 16:12
Location: Bavaria, Germany

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#389

Post by Bernd R » 01 Mar 2009, 18:01

Peter, while I was preparing the below you posted about I./IR 73. What a timing !! 8-) :)
So, are we able to say now, the date 18. is secure and confirmed ?

Klaus-Henning von Schmeling-Diringshofen (1910-1939)
A soldier of jewish descent who was thrown out of the Reichswehr in 1933 due to the regulations of the NS racial laws, served in China then with the staff of GenO von Seeckt (training of the Tschiang Kai-schek troops) from 1934-1938, came back to Germany and received the “Deutschblütigkeitserklärung” [classified arian for the record], re-entered service as a Hauptmann, and was killed in action in the Polish campaign as one of the first officers serving his homeland.

Klaus-Henning was born on 22.12.1910 in Bromberg as the second son of Henning Julius von Schmeling-Diringshofen and his first wife Cläre, geb. Born. He spent his youth in the several garrisons of his father (Schneidemühl most of the time). After the divorce of his parents in 1921 he stayed with his mother in Berlin-Lichterfelde. He finished school with the “Abitur” and entered service of the Reichswehr in the II.(Jäger-) Bataillon of Infanterie-Regiment 4, Kolberg (Kolberger Jäger ; carrying the tradition of : Pommersches Jäger-Bataillon “Fürst Bismarck” Nr. 2).
In 1933 he was promoted to Leutnant. His Bataillons-Kommandeur was the later GFM Erich von Manstein, who was Kdr. of the Kolberger Jäger from 1931-1934, promoted to Oberst during this time. When the NS racial laws were put into practice throughout the country and within the Reichswehr especially he was thrown out of the army according to the regulations that no officers of jewish descent were allowed to stay in service. This was a bitter blow for him. It is not quite clear if he was regarded as a Jew or a half or quarter jew per the definitions and the terminology of the racial laws (not known for sure if his mother was classified jewish or one of the grand-parents). What happened was, in the words of the time, he was kept from serving his fatherland under the flags of the N. furtheron [“seinem Vaterland weiterhin unter den Fahnen des Nationalsozialismus zu dienen”].
Various sources state that Oberst von Manstein did forward a written protest against this treatment of this Leutnant serving under his command. There was no way out and with the help of the regimental cdr. [and probably von Manstein, too] Klaus-Henning was posted to the staff of GenO von Seeckt. This staff of hand-picked and capable personnel was established to support the Chinese National Gouvernment and to train the National Chinese Army. From 1934-1938 Klaus-Henning served as a high respected officer there, since 1935 under the command of General Alexander von Falkenhausen. Most of the time in Nanking, later in Tschungking. After the German-Japanese pact in autumn 1938, the time of this detachment had to end and the officers had to leave China (otherwise they had to face the loss of their german citizenship).
It was offered and promised to Klaus-Henning that he can re-enter the army, taking into account the years of service in China. In addition he was declared arian ; he received a so-called “Bescheinigung, dass er Arier sei” (so-called “Deutschblütigkeitserklärung”).
His brother-in-law Alexander tells the story that – like he was told as a child – Klaus-Henning was travelling with a cargo-steamer and this vessel sunk in heavy waters at the Galizian Coast – Klaus-Henning was able to save his pure life only. Soon after arriving in Germany in september 1938, he in fact took the opportunity to proceed with his military carrer and went on to become Kompaniechef 1./Infanterie-Regiment 73, Celle, in the rank of Hauptmann. With this unit he went into war.
The hardest battle which would fullfil his fate was to become known in german as the “Schlacht an der Bzura”. Very heavy combats were in progress in the area Ruszki - Adamowa Góra for at least four days (16.09. - 19.09.). The whole area and parts of it were passing from hands to hands many times. Klaus-Henning was killed in action during these fightings near Dwor Ruszki (manor [Gut] Ruszki) near the village Adamowa Góra. According to the records of Hauptmann Chill from I. Btl. Infanterie-Regiment 73, he was fatally wounded in the early hours of September 18th ("kurz nach 4 Uhr gefallen") during a Polish attack with heavy weapons against the positions guarded by his 1. Kp. (1) To complete the picture it is to state that in later times an obituary notice [Todesanzeige] was found (old newspaper) in the 1933 von Schmeling family book, which shows the death date of September 19th. (most probably a mistaken message to the family for any reason).

Born in Silesia, starting a military career as a “Kolberger Jäger” and being a protegé of the later GFM von Manstein, service in China with GenO von Seeckt, returning home and re-entering the Wehrmacht, officially classified to be an “Arier”, and loosing his young life of 28 years in the third week of the Polish campaign might show a spotlight of the simultaneously complex and strange circumstances of that time in history.

(1) the original report reads :
"18.September, Schlacht an der Bzura

Die Nacht war wieder sehr warm, sodaß die Truppe im Freien gut biwakieren konnte. Feinberührung war nirgends vorhanden, sodaß die Feldposten ganz "friedensmäßig" aufziehen konnten.
Die vordersten Feldposten wurden von dem Strassenkreuz bei D.Ruszki etwa 1000m nach Westen und Nordwesten vorgeschoben. Feldwebel Spötter von der 1.Kp. befahl die vorderste Feldwache.
Um Mitternacht hörten die Posten aus der Ferne polnische Laute herüberhallen.........
.....Schon nach kurzer Zeit wurde es auf der ganzen Front der 1.Kp. lebhaft. Polnische Kräfte versuchten im Schutze der beiden Strassengräben auf Ruszki vorzukommen. Als gegen 2 Uhr der polnische Druck stärker wurde, forderte Hptm.von Schmeling VErstärkungen an.....
........
Gegen 4 Uhr morgens setzte bei völliger Dunkelheit ein erneuter polnischer Angriff ein, der mit großen Waffen vorgetragen wurde. In diesem Augenblick meldete die 1.Kp., daß Hptm. von Schmeling tödlich verwundet verwundet worden sei und der Feind so stark angriffe, daß die Kompanie nach Ausfall von sechs leichten MG und einem s.M.G. nicht mehr in der Lage sei, die befohlenen Linie zu halten...."
Sources :
1) Genealogisches Handbuch des Adels,
Adlige Häuser B Band VII, 1965:
Klaus-Henning Alexander Eberhard v.S.-D.
geb. 22.12.1910 Bromberg
gest. 18.9.1939 bei Kutno
2) Geschichte des Geschlechts von Schmeling, von Schmeling-Diringshofen und Blecken von Schmeling , Hrsg. Kurt von Schmeling, Eschweiler, verfaßt und redigiert von Hans Wätjen, Bremen 1970 [Familienbuch 1970]
3) Schmelinge in Pommern 1283 – 1933 , Hrsg. Dr. Wilhelm von Schmeling, verfaßt und redigiert von Regierungsrat a.D. Dr. Dr. Wilhelm von Schmeling, Berlin-Friedenau, 1933 [Familienbuch 1933]
- in this book the Todesanzeige [obituary notice] was found (file itself)
4) Familienbuch von Schmeling u.a. , Alexander von Schmeling-Diringshofen, 3. Auflage 1995
[Alexander is the brother-in-law (Halbbruder) to Klaus-Henning, 4th son from 2nd marriage]
5) family website
http://www.jvsd.de/schmeling/lnl222.htm
(and I got kind help by the site administrator)

in addition (concerning the aspect of his jewish descent ; parts found online and in the works above ; this is not finally researched and confirmed in every detail) those works not used directly :
- Erich von Manstein, Verlorene Siege
- Bryan Martin Rigg, Hitlers Jewish Soldiers
(Rigg obviously used the Personalakte of Klaus-Henning ; in Bundesarchiv-Militärarchiv Freiburg)


Thanks for allowing this short “extra”. I stumbled upon the website and did notice not less than three differences of the data. This is an example also how difficult it can be to fix precise data.

With regard to the listing :
von Schmeling-Diringshofen Claus-Henning, 22.09.1910, Hptm., Kdr. 1./I. R. 73, 19. Div., 18.09.1939 (n. Verw. v. 17.09.), VB, O. v. Knobelsdorff „19. Panzer-Division 1939 – 1945”
1) the name
should be Klaus-Henning ; see Todesanzeige (the family has to know this at least), GenHdA, and in addition : the christian name Klaus with a “C” appears a single time only in the family history for a younger member born 1963 in Celle ; all others are spelled with a “K”
2) the date of birth
should be 22.12.1910 per the sources above
3) the date of death
should be 18. 09. most likely ; what makes this tricky is the death obituary – 19. !!
One should assume that the family back in Sep 1939 should have known this for sure ; but, can we rule out that they were informed with a wrong date, or with a date not known for sure/or better that days ?
So, Peter, you provided this from the v. Knobelsdorff divisional history I think. Can you look up again and tell exactly what’s stated there, please ?
WIA 17.09., died during night 17./18. then (?). Or indeed in the night to 19. (?).
4) the location
Kutno denotes the bigger area after all.

Best regards
Bernd

edited per new and more precise informations / 3 March 09 / Bernd

Piotr Kapuscinski
Host - Allied sections
Posts: 3724
Joined: 12 Jul 2006, 20:17
Location: Poland
Contact:

Re: Poland 1939: KIA High ranking officers

#390

Post by Piotr Kapuscinski » 01 Mar 2009, 22:16

Bernd, thanks for this excellent input!
So, Peter, you provided this from the v. Knobelsdorff divisional history I think. Can you look up again and tell exactly what’s stated there, please ?
WIA 17.09., died during night 17./18. then (?). Or indeed in the night to 19. (?).
There is stated that he was WIA on 17.09.1939 and later died of these wounds. But this is probably a mistake.

I think that info that he was KIA on 18.09.1939 is correct (maybe it was during the night from 17th to 18th and that's why there are some differences in sources?). Maybe he was WIA and died of these wounds very soon after he was WIA, and that is why some sources say that he died of wounds and some other count him as KIA?
4) the location
Kutno denotes the bigger area after all.
The location is absolutely clear. Both sources give the same location. It was certainly "bei Dwor Ruszki" near Adamowa Gora.

Adamowa Gora = settlement.
Dwor Ruszki = manor Ruszki (dwor = manor in Polish) located near Adamowa Gora.

Very heavy combats were in progress in the area Ruszki - Adamowa Gora for at least four days (16.09 - 19.09) or even longer.

The whole area and parts of it were passing from hands to hands many times.

Here is something about combats of 4. Panzer-Division and LAH near Dwor Ruszki and Adamowa Gora on 16.09.1939:

http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic. ... 5&t=146348

Map of this area on 16.09.1939 and 17.09.1939:

Image
So, are we able to say now, the date 18. is secure and confirmed ?
In my opinion - yes. ;)

------------------------------------------

Btw - with regard to 21. Infanterie-Division:

I have just discovered that the history of 21. Infanterie-Division is not fully reliable if it comes to casualties of this division.

One more officer from Infanterie-Regiment 3.:
Gichtmeyer, -, Lt. d. R., I. R. 3, 21. Div., -, H. Gru. Nord
So casualties of the division were de facto higher than its history says - at least one officer KIA more.

If at least one officer KIA more, then most probably also at least around 50 - 55 soldiers and NCOs killed more - as casualty ratio officers : soldiers in this division when it comes to KIA and MIA was 1 : 54,4 according the data from the divisional history.

I have also found the missing officer from 21. Infanterie-Division:
Tegtmeyer, -, Lt., A. A. 21, 21. Div., -, H. Gru. Nord
I will edit my post above and add him there.

So we have got more than complete casualty list of 21. Infanterie-Division :wink:.

Best regards,
Peter

PS:

What was Gichtmeyer's date of death?

Post Reply

Return to “The Dieter Zinke Axis Biographical Research Section”