Yes it's correct fantasy you only have to read the above posts by offizier1916 and Stiltzkin in the above posts to see the fantasy world people live in.Pena V wrote:Sid,
Sid Guttridge wrote:If you look at AHF's W-SS descriptions, they are usually helpful in this regard. For instance, for 38th W-SS Division it gives such context as, "Although it was called a division it never had more than a brigade's strength (roughly around 6000 men)." In other cases, their OB (perhaps four infabtry battalions and an artillery battalion, give the game away.As I have said before I have no problems admitting that the 38th never had more than a brigades strenght but if you call the 38th a division are you living in a fantasy land? AHF has chosen to call the 38th a division although it never had more than a brigade's strength.Pena V wrote:Pena V wrote:the late SS-Divisions were weak This is not an issue. The issue here is that if someone calls them divisions is it right to say that he j keenan wrote: is living in Fantasy land
If you would call the 38th a brigade instead of a division it wouldn't be historically correct. As a side effect it could improve the image of Waffen-SS like this:
A says: The 38th SS Division didn't do so well in 1945.
B says: The 38th was actually a Brigade.
A says: If it was only a brigade then the performance was OK.
Regards,
Pena V
Elite tanks crews ?
Elite if you have massive tanks ?
The SS had the best crews ?
The bigger the unit the less casualties ?
The SS was mainly made up of volunteers it goes on and on Fantasy starts with 38 divis how many did they have in 39 ?