A Question about Snipers and Tanks
- Brian Von Stauffenberg
- Member
- Posts: 166
- Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 00:12
- Location: UK
A Question about Snipers and Tanks
I have often wondered what tactics a sniper would use when/if they ever attempted to shoot at a tank, i mean could they shoot through the small slot the driver would look through, would/ could they fire into the Barrell of the Tank to set off the round within, did they attempt to shoot the commander if he was visible, are there any examples of Snipers used against armour? :
Sniper target selection - sniper key targets
from US Army field manual for snipers (FM 23 10)
1. Sniper - no. 1 target for sniper team because it's snipers natural enemy
2. Dog tracking teams - the sniper engages dog's handler first
3. Scouts - they are key observers for enemy force
4. Officers
5. NCOs
6. Vehicle commanders and drivers
7. Communication personnel
8. Weapon crews
9. Optics on vehicles
10. Communication and radar equipment
11. Weapon systems
From this I make that shooting though some small slot in the tank or even into the barrel would be foolish because the sniper would only reveal his position. One the other hand the chances of successful hit would be minimal.
MaPen
from US Army field manual for snipers (FM 23 10)
1. Sniper - no. 1 target for sniper team because it's snipers natural enemy
2. Dog tracking teams - the sniper engages dog's handler first
3. Scouts - they are key observers for enemy force
4. Officers
5. NCOs
6. Vehicle commanders and drivers
7. Communication personnel
8. Weapon crews
9. Optics on vehicles
10. Communication and radar equipment
11. Weapon systems
From this I make that shooting though some small slot in the tank or even into the barrel would be foolish because the sniper would only reveal his position. One the other hand the chances of successful hit would be minimal.
MaPen
I'm sure the are accounts of snipers shooting at tanks, probably most happened on the Eastern Front. I don't recall any off-hand but I remember reading about some German tank commanders getting shot while in the turret cupola.
As for tactics, common sense would tell me to shoot only the exposed crew members, as the vision ports had bullet resistant glass. A smart sniper would let the tank roll by and wait for an easier target to come along.
As for tactics, common sense would tell me to shoot only the exposed crew members, as the vision ports had bullet resistant glass. A smart sniper would let the tank roll by and wait for an easier target to come along.
- David Lehmann
- Member
- Posts: 2863
- Joined: 01 Apr 2002, 11:50
- Location: France
german sniper
On the east front in urban fights especially like in Stalingrad many german soldiers used small caliber carbines (.22 LR) ... these guns are not noisy and russians couldn't localize the sniper ...
- Christian Ankerstjerne
- Forum Staff
- Posts: 14050
- Joined: 10 Mar 2002, 15:07
- Location: Denmark
- Contact:
The tank commander, while standing in his copula, is an often taken target - without the commander, the tank is more or less blind, as the periscopes only offers limited visibility.
For instance, Erich Barkmann (i believe it was) once recieved a reserve Panther which still displayed some blood on the copula from the commander... Not a very nice thing to be reminded of...
For instance, Erich Barkmann (i believe it was) once recieved a reserve Panther which still displayed some blood on the copula from the commander... Not a very nice thing to be reminded of...
Snipers
It depends of what kind of sniper we are talking about.
1. ATR sniper - in this case, the man is supposed to aim and hit those areas of the tank where the armor is thinner than 30mm( grilles over the radiators etc) to provoke a breakdown; a direct hit on a light-medium tank from a heavy ATR( like the Finnish L-39) could penetrate almost any area of the armor, but when dealing with a KV-1 or IS-2, he should do as above;
2. Conventional-rifle sniper - he is supposed to take from one bullet the commander(usually the commanders rode with the cupola opened, to have better visibility);
3. Heavy rifle sniper - a quite unconventional type; the Danish army had used between the wars sidecar-motorcycle troops armed with the 20mm Madsen machine-cannon(scaled-up version of the 8mm Madsen machine-gun). Not being possible to fire the gun while driving, the Danes were trained to camouflage their vehicle and shoot, then change their position, in a sniper-like hit-and-run tactic. During the four hours of combat between the Danish Army and the German one, the Danes lost 13 men, while knocking out 13 German armored cars and 2 PzKpfw I light tanks.
http://mailer.fsu.edu/~akirk/tanks/denmark/denmark.html
~Ovidius
1. ATR sniper - in this case, the man is supposed to aim and hit those areas of the tank where the armor is thinner than 30mm( grilles over the radiators etc) to provoke a breakdown; a direct hit on a light-medium tank from a heavy ATR( like the Finnish L-39) could penetrate almost any area of the armor, but when dealing with a KV-1 or IS-2, he should do as above;
2. Conventional-rifle sniper - he is supposed to take from one bullet the commander(usually the commanders rode with the cupola opened, to have better visibility);
3. Heavy rifle sniper - a quite unconventional type; the Danish army had used between the wars sidecar-motorcycle troops armed with the 20mm Madsen machine-cannon(scaled-up version of the 8mm Madsen machine-gun). Not being possible to fire the gun while driving, the Danes were trained to camouflage their vehicle and shoot, then change their position, in a sniper-like hit-and-run tactic. During the four hours of combat between the Danish Army and the German one, the Danes lost 13 men, while knocking out 13 German armored cars and 2 PzKpfw I light tanks.
http://mailer.fsu.edu/~akirk/tanks/denmark/denmark.html
~Ovidius
- Brian Von Stauffenberg
- Member
- Posts: 166
- Joined: 13 Mar 2002, 00:12
- Location: UK
Very Interesting Obvidious
Thanks for the good info, i wasnt aware that Denmark actually had combat with Germany allbeit four hours, can you suggest a resource to read more about this?
- David Lehmann
- Member
- Posts: 2863
- Joined: 01 Apr 2002, 11:50
- Location: France
- Christian Ankerstjerne
- Forum Staff
- Posts: 14050
- Joined: 10 Mar 2002, 15:07
- Location: Denmark
- Contact:
You might want to look at this thread:
http://pub28.ezboard.com/fbuildersparad ... =602.topic
It has some info about the Danish fighting, although not much, and the 20mm Madsen. I am not sure I agree with Ovidius that these were in fact sniper 'rifles', as they were apparent to the Germans - they just thought they were normal machine guns, though, and got themselve quite a scare...
I think I've written a little something on the topic here and there on the old forum, so you might wanna google around a bit. Otherwise, George Parada has a fine article on http://www.achtungpanzer.com
FP
http://pub28.ezboard.com/fbuildersparad ... =602.topic
It has some info about the Danish fighting, although not much, and the 20mm Madsen. I am not sure I agree with Ovidius that these were in fact sniper 'rifles', as they were apparent to the Germans - they just thought they were normal machine guns, though, and got themselve quite a scare...
I think I've written a little something on the topic here and there on the old forum, so you might wanna google around a bit. Otherwise, George Parada has a fine article on http://www.achtungpanzer.com
FP