- Posts: 6002
- Joined: 13 Jan 2005 18:44
- Location: USA
http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic. ... 585#734585
You might also try the search function. There may already have been other discussions on this subject as it is pretty popular.
- Posts: 6647
- Joined: 17 Feb 2004 01:12
- Location: Europe
Here's an okayish narrative of events leading to the surrender.
- Posts: 68
- Joined: 30 Jan 2006 11:42
- Location: Hervey Bay, Queensland, Australia
The outer perimeter posts were initially held by 6 infantry battalions, with 6 in reserve. By early May the Indians had taken over the extreme northwestern sector, and the Australian Army Service Corps (AASC) the extreme northeastern sector - the last being the "quietest" sectior". At the same time the rest of the outer perimeter was held by 7 Australian battalions, with 5 in reserve.
By 13 April, disposed around Tobruk were 3 Italian divisions and 1 ("light") German division, with numerous artillery, machine-gun, engineer and reconnaissance units attached. These Axis forces changed in size and composition during the siege, but always outnumbered the Australians
The only real gain made by the Germans was the "Salient" in the southwestern corner, where they captured a number of posts in the oter perimeter. Despite Australian attempts - at heavy cost - to regain this lost ground, it remained in German hands until the end of the siege.
The "offensive defence" instituted by Gen Morshead is illustrated no better than in the 9th Division intelligence summary for 15 April: "1 Bn, 62 Regt, Trento Division - completely captured" - by an Australian infantry platoon supported by a section of Bren-gun carriers.
At night, "No-Man's Land" became "Australia Land", which kept the Axis forces permanently on the alert against Australian patrols, which were of two types - reconnaissance and offensive. The former gave Morshead precise information on Axis dispositions, while the latter caused many casualties and the capture of personnel and weapons.
That is why it amazes me that 33,000 defenders were over-run so easily in the end by two German Panzer Divisions, one Italian Armoured Division and one Italian Motorized Division - all at reduced strength owing to previous fighting.