The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Discussions on all aspects of the Japanese Empire, from the capture of Taiwan until the end of the Second World War.
User avatar
wm
Member
Posts: 6381
Joined: 29 Dec 2006 20:11
Location: Poland

The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by wm » 01 May 2021 07:34

True or false?
The Japanese on the other hand, under the leadership of types like Inuzuka, felt that if the Jews controlled the financial world, then the Japanese in turn would control them. That would ensure Imperial Japan would rule the world with the most efficiency.
This is why I call into question the motives of the man who has come to be known as the Schindler of Japan, Chiune Sugihara.
Sugihara was a Japanese diplomat who spoke fluent Russian and served as the Vice Counsel for the Japanese Empire in Lithuania. He is credited with saving between 4,500 and 6,000 Jewish people who were fleeing the Nazis and Soviets by providing them with transit visas that would allow them to pass through Japanese territory. (This was the real-life version of the letters of transit that was central to the plot of the classic film Casablanca.)

It is my opinion that the only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape from Russia-occupied Lithuania to sanctuary of the Jewish ghetto in Japanese-held Shanghai or to Kobe, Japan, was to be used as slaves by the Empire of Japan.

We should not forget Sugihara served a fascist government that murdered 22 million people during the war in Asia and the Pacific from 1927-1945. Before Sugihara entered the foreign service, he had served in the Imperial Japanese Army in Korea where numerous crimes against the people of Korea occurred. A large majority of the Comfort Women forced into prostitution by the Japanese military came from Korea. As a diplomat in the 1930s, Sugihara served in Manchuria and witnessed firsthand Japan’s crimes against humanity in that region. He gave up his position in 1935 over the crimes witnessed, but continued to serve Emperor Hirohito and eventually became the Vice-Consul of the Japanese Consulate in Kaunas, Lithuania. In this position, he helped thousands of Jews leave Europe as Stalin took over the Baltic States in the summer of 1940. When Hitler took over this area in June 1941, he moved his diplomatic office to Königsberg, Germany; from 1941 to 1942, he became Consul General in Nazi-occupied Prague, Czechoslovakia. From 1942 to 1944, he worked as the Consul General in Bucharest, Romania, another Fascist regime.

So why praise a man, like Sugihara, who loyally served a regime that wanted to use Jews and really did not care about them? Why praise a man who loyally served a regime whose crimes he witnessed firsthand while stationed in Manchuria and did nothing about it? Why praise a man who served his fascist regime by working hard at his duties in Nazi Germany, Nazi-occupied Czechoslovakia and fascist Romania? Sugihara never tried saving Jews when stationed in these areas. He never spoke out after the war against Imperial Japanese leaders and their crimes against humanity. And he never described why this fascist regime allowed him to issue transit papers to Jews to come to its territory.
Bryan Mark Rigg, author and historian ("Lives of Hitler's Jewish Soldiers", "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers", "Rescued from the Reich", "The Rabbi Saved by Hitler's Soldiers") in "Study of the Holocaust", a private Facebook group.

jerryasher
Member
Posts: 386
Joined: 27 Jul 2018 22:31
Location: California, USA

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by jerryasher » 01 May 2021 23:34

What a bizarre question. Questioning motivations will almost by definition lead to inconclusive response, A question is something that if you get an answer to, it makes a difference.

adachi
Member
Posts: 18
Joined: 10 Sep 2020 01:36
Location: Nagoya

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by adachi » 02 May 2021 03:21

I have looked over some of Rigg's works and to be frank he is not a historian I would assign much credibility to, especially on his works regarding Japan. At some point he had reached out to me to help answer questions pertaining to the Japanese Navy for him but his hatred towards Japanese people made me feel so uncomfortable I eventually had to cease contact with him. Unfortunately his personal bias against Japan has erroded his ability to properly write on subjects related to Japan in WWII.

hysteric
Member
Posts: 105
Joined: 09 Apr 2015 00:18
Location: North America

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by hysteric » 02 May 2021 17:20

wm wrote:
01 May 2021 07:34
True or false?
Absurd attempt at character assassination! Shame on you for posting this on here.

hysteric

User avatar
wm
Member
Posts: 6381
Joined: 29 Dec 2006 20:11
Location: Poland

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by wm » 02 May 2021 18:14

Maybe he isn't a historian, I don't know, but he says he is.
He is a public figure; his statement was public too.
What he wrote is equivalent to an astronomer claiming the Moon is made from white cheese, isn't it?
Do you really believe that Sugihara ran a slave harvesting operation for Japan?
Aren't you concerned that he assassinated the character of Sugihara or even his own by peddling fake history?

Don't you think his potential readers deserve a warning especially that his "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers" is so well known all around the world? Please explain.

User avatar
Takao
Member
Posts: 3301
Joined: 10 Mar 2002 19:27
Location: Reading, Pa

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by Takao » 04 May 2021 20:34

wm wrote:
02 May 2021 18:14
Maybe he isn't a historian, I don't know, but he says he is.
He is a public figure; his statement was public too.
What he wrote is equivalent to an astronomer claiming the Moon is made from white cheese, isn't it?
Do you really believe that Sugihara ran a slave harvesting operation for Japan?
Aren't you concerned that he assassinated the character of Sugihara or even his own by peddling fake history?

Don't you think his potential readers deserve a warning especially that his "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers" is so well known all around the world? Please explain.
Really...

Given your puerile response of "True or false?" to Rigg's statement.

Me thinks your are just trying to "stir the pot."

User avatar
wm
Member
Posts: 6381
Joined: 29 Dec 2006 20:11
Location: Poland

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by wm » 04 May 2021 20:55

Yes, really. I've done many such "true or false" shticks already.

User avatar
Takao
Member
Posts: 3301
Joined: 10 Mar 2002 19:27
Location: Reading, Pa

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by Takao » 04 May 2021 22:06

wm wrote:
04 May 2021 20:55
Yes, really. I've done many such "true or false" shticks already.
Ok...So you are looking to constructively contribute to this discussion.

Then, what are your answers to these questions?

What he wrote is equivalent to an astronomer claiming the Moon is made from white cheese, isn't it?
Do you really believe that Sugihara ran a slave harvesting operation for Japan?
Aren't you concerned that he assassinated the character of Sugihara or even his own by peddling fake history?

Don't you think his potential readers deserve a warning especially that his "Hitler's Jewish Soldiers" is so well known all around the world? Please explain.

User avatar
wm
Member
Posts: 6381
Joined: 29 Dec 2006 20:11
Location: Poland

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by wm » 04 May 2021 23:57

The questions were for the person with the cool nick - "hysteric" and nobody else.

User avatar
Takao
Member
Posts: 3301
Joined: 10 Mar 2002 19:27
Location: Reading, Pa

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by Takao » 05 May 2021 01:40

Well, now they are my questions to you.

Answers please.

michael mills
Member
Posts: 8894
Joined: 11 Mar 2002 12:42
Location: Sydney, Australia

Re: The only reason Japan allowed Sugihara to assist Jews’ escape ... was to be used as slaves

Post by michael mills » 28 Jul 2021 04:44

The assertions by Rigg are of course nonsense, but mainly because he accepts the myth of Sugihara, namely that his main function was "rescuing" Jews from Lithuania by issuing them transit visas to cross Soviet territory in order to reach Japan. The only way his assertions differ from the myth is that he ascribes a sinister motive to Sugihara's actions, namely that he was doing it on the orders of the Japanese Government in order to use the "rescued" jews as slave labour.

Some of what Rigg writes is historically correct. He was an intelligence agent operating under diplomatic cover, and his main function was to spy on Soviet activities, in which function he worked close collaboration with Polish intelligence agents. He was posted to the Japanese consulate in Kaunas, Lithuania, in November 1939, ie after it had come under Soviet domination in accordance with the provisions of the German-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact. His undercover role in that position was to observe and report on Soviet troop movements in the Baltic area.

At that time there was a large number of Polish refugees in Lithuania who had fled from the German-occupied part of Poland. Among them were Polish official personnel, including intelligence agents with whom he had previously worked, and he knew that they were in potential danger from the Soviet military authorities who were now present in Lithuania and dominated it. Sugihara began an action to rescue Polish personnel from Soviet persecution by issuing them transit visas to cross Soviet territory and enter Japan. Whether he commenced that action on the orders of the Japanese Government or with its authorisation, or was acting entirely on his own initiative, seems to be uncertain as far as I know.

A group of Polish-Jewish refugees found out about Sugihara's actions to assist Polish official personnel leave Lithuania, and approached him with the request to issue transit visas to them also. After some hesitation, he began issuing visas to the Jewish refugees, and all the indications are that he did that on his own initiative, and not on the orders of the Japanese Government; the real reason why he decided to do that remains unclear, but it most certainly was not to save the Jews from the Germans, since at the time he was issuing visas Lithuania was under Soviet control and there was no sign that it would ever fall under German control.

After Lithuania was finally annexed by the Soviet Union in August 1940, all diplomatic and consular offices of foreign nations in Lithuania were ordered closed, and Sugihara left the country with the rest of the Japanese staff in September, ie almost a full year before the German conquest of Lithuania. He was then posted to the Japanese consulate in Prague, which was no longer the capital of an independent country, since Bohemia-Moravia was now a German protectorate.

The bottom line is that Sugihara's main function while posted to the Japanese Consulate in Kaunas was not the rescuing of Jews, but rather the rescuing of Polish personnel under the threat of persecution by the Soviet occupiers. Accordingly, he cannot have been harvesting Jewish slaves for Japan, since assisting Jews to leave Lithuania and go to Japan was not his main function, and was not something he was doing on the orders of the Japanese Government.

The issue here is not Sugihara's reputation, since contrary to the myth he was not a hero rescuing Jews from the danger of death at German hands. The real issue is the historical truth about Sugihara's activities in Lithuania between November 1939 and September 1940, and Rigg's claims are just as much a perversion of that historical truth as is the myth of the saintly Sugihara, heroic rescuer of Jews.

Return to “Japan at War 1895-1945”