Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
Walls have to be 2 meter at each side, and not as on the SHM plan 1 m 50 on the frontal (enemy side)
no is good 1,5 meter on all plan i see here
AC
no is good 1,5 meter on all plan i see here
AC
- dirk Peeters
- Member
- Posts: 6568
- Joined: 24 May 2011, 21:18
- Location: Heist op den Berg Belgium
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
excuse me the walls are 2 meter
But you can make them 1m 50 it s a free world ...
SHM states also 2 meter and if you make the walls 1m 50 it s even worse at the interior
Dirk
But you can make them 1m 50 it s a free world ...
SHM states also 2 meter and if you make the walls 1m 50 it s even worse at the interior
Dirk
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
excuse me i see only 1,5 m on ALL Plan !
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
S_haule wrote:Dear Dirk T.dterrier wrote:Hello Jos,
I have found this drawing of the Leitstand of batt Hessen in the book of Yannick Rose "1940/1944 L'Artillerie Côtière de L'Est Cotentin HKAR1261" on page 124.
This leitstand was belonging in 1942 to the S.B. (k) 317.
You can see that In comparison with the drawing i think of Dirk Peeters of the Leitstand of batt St Adress that both leitstands as you mentioned are the same model.
Grtz.
Dirk T.
I'm agree ta share information but anyway, I like to decide by myselft what I want to share in forums! It is the only existing measurement of the Fort de Ste Adresse Leitstand made before it was covered with earth
Thanks to Dirk Peeters for having underline that I'm the maker of this drawing.
Regards,
Sébastien Haule
OK not a problem Mr. Haule. I didn't know that the drawing was from you. I ask next time at Dirk P. if the drawing iss from him or not.
Dirk T
- dirk Peeters
- Member
- Posts: 6568
- Joined: 24 May 2011, 21:18
- Location: Heist op den Berg Belgium
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
Only i have a problem with the entrance
I ll think error and it has to be like Seb Haule his plan but for that we can t be sure without pictures Here is your plan its even marked AC BP but in reality it is SHM so beter say it s SHM plan in the future if as you say you didn t enter it
We never write down we measured a bunker without entering
You can easily see in our plans which one hasn t been measured at all... (no written measurements inside)
Like on the Kora Karolla plans of the gunpits (see on this forum)
the parts we didn t measure are without measurements
- dirk Peeters
- Member
- Posts: 6568
- Joined: 24 May 2011, 21:18
- Location: Heist op den Berg Belgium
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
as you say ... all plans have 1 m 50 in front ..... normal then if the backside is 2 meter as indicated on your plan...Where do you ever find a bunker with this (enemy side 1 m 50 rear side 2 meter ... It s not logical but if you wish it s a free world
I used your plan Alain .... go and see all the other plans also ... All are using the same errors .....as SHM started it- dirk Peeters
- Member
- Posts: 6568
- Joined: 24 May 2011, 21:18
- Location: Heist op den Berg Belgium
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
You are absolutely right for the "interior wall of 1 m 50 even i put it in my drawing
but a little more to the left and right it becomes 2 meter Why do i think that ?
Logic see german plan of 636 .... you see it s also like that 1 m 50 for the " interior wall" and two meter when it becomes exterior ...
And this is logic Alain that s why even the the german drawing gives 1 m 50 and 2 meter like we did from the first time
and sorry for the SHM drawing (and others) they are full of errors ....
but a little more to the left and right it becomes 2 meter Why do i think that ?
Logic see german plan of 636 .... you see it s also like that 1 m 50 for the " interior wall" and two meter when it becomes exterior ...
And this is logic Alain that s why even the the german drawing gives 1 m 50 and 2 meter like we did from the first time
and sorry for the SHM drawing (and others) they are full of errors ....
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
yes i'am agree with you !
AC
AC
- dirk Peeters
- Member
- Posts: 6568
- Joined: 24 May 2011, 21:18
- Location: Heist op den Berg Belgium
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
haha you change quickly
at post nr 46 and 48 (18h48) you stated something else
But ok
glad you changed your opinion because of our proofs
we ll continue to share info for all here and work together
Dirk
at post nr 46 and 48 (18h48) you stated something else
But ok
glad you changed your opinion because of our proofs
we ll continue to share info for all here and work together
Dirk
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
I had to look and to understand well that you stand out in English which is not my language and furthermore I had to look for the children in the judo thus I was not behind my computer
AC
AC
Re: Commandposts La Pernelle and St Adresse
Hello
Obviously there were a lot of german positions around La Pernelle, according to maps.
Anyone who can explain the different positions for me?
Regards
Kurt
kstdk
Obviously there were a lot of german positions around La Pernelle, according to maps.
Anyone who can explain the different positions for me?
Regards
Kurt
kstdk