Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Hi there,
In regard to my coming visit to Normandy, I'm looking for more info about Stützpunkt 277 MKB York, more in particularly...
1. Are the casemates M271 or M272 ?
2. What is the difference between those two ( besides that a M272 is smaller ), I found a drawing of a M272 but not from a M271.
3. Can anybody confirm that the name "York" relates to "Johann David Ludwig Graf Yorck ( also spelled as York ) von Wartenburg" a former Prussian Generalfeldmarschall ?
Thx in advance
Patrick
In regard to my coming visit to Normandy, I'm looking for more info about Stützpunkt 277 MKB York, more in particularly...
1. Are the casemates M271 or M272 ?
2. What is the difference between those two ( besides that a M272 is smaller ), I found a drawing of a M272 but not from a M271.
3. Can anybody confirm that the name "York" relates to "Johann David Ludwig Graf Yorck ( also spelled as York ) von Wartenburg" a former Prussian Generalfeldmarschall ?
Thx in advance
Patrick
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Patrick
Afaik there is no original drawing of the M 271 known so we can't be sure if this is the bunker in Yor(c)k or a M 272 abg
For the name both names were used in several documents York and Yorck
Afaik there is no original drawing of the M 271 known so we can't be sure if this is the bunker in Yor(c)k or a M 272 abg
For the name both names were used in several documents York and Yorck
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Jos, bedankt voor de info !
The only difference that I have found
M271 Width 12,50 Depth 16,50 Height 7,70
M272 Width 12,50 Depth 13,50 Height 7,10
However as MKB York housed the same guns as MKB Heerenduin the chances are very high that they used the same Regelbau i.e. M272
Furthermore the name "Yor(c)k refers (more than) probably to our above mentioned Prussian Generalfeldmarschall, same as MKB Brommy named after Konteradmiral Karl Rudolf Brommy.
Regards
Patrick
The only difference that I have found
M271 Width 12,50 Depth 16,50 Height 7,70
M272 Width 12,50 Depth 13,50 Height 7,10
However as MKB York housed the same guns as MKB Heerenduin the chances are very high that they used the same Regelbau i.e. M272
Furthermore the name "Yor(c)k refers (more than) probably to our above mentioned Prussian Generalfeldmarschall, same as MKB Brommy named after Konteradmiral Karl Rudolf Brommy.
Regards
Patrick
- AvB
- Financial supporter
- Posts: 3425
- Joined: 20 Jun 2004, 01:00
- Location: Utrecht, Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
@jos. Is Rolf's plan of a M 271 based on Batterie Yorck?
The difference is visible in the gun room. The M 272 back wall is 'flat'. The M 271's walls are in an angle.
The difference is visible in the gun room. The M 272 back wall is 'flat'. The M 271's walls are in an angle.
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Thx AvB for the pictures
Ah Ok, I see it and that is the only difference...
So the M270 is than also different from M271/72...
M270 Width 12,80 Depth 18,80 Height 6,80
Ah Ok, I see it and that is the only difference...
So the M270 is than also different from M271/72...
M270 Width 12,80 Depth 18,80 Height 6,80
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Hello
@ Arthur Yes Rudi combined the building plans named with M 271 with the drawing of York,
I never seen a original drawing of the M 271 only names with Schartenstand M 271 ( planned Cadzand and OT Cherbourg )
A option could be that B. York had no St ammo bunkers like Heerenduin , so they expanded the two ammo niche's
@ Patrick agree we see B. Tirpitz , Ramin , Knorr and many other German naval officers
@ Arthur Yes Rudi combined the building plans named with M 271 with the drawing of York,
I never seen a original drawing of the M 271 only names with Schartenstand M 271 ( planned Cadzand and OT Cherbourg )
A option could be that B. York had no St ammo bunkers like Heerenduin , so they expanded the two ammo niche's
@ Patrick agree we see B. Tirpitz , Ramin , Knorr and many other German naval officers
- AvB
- Financial supporter
- Posts: 3425
- Joined: 20 Jun 2004, 01:00
- Location: Utrecht, Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Yes M 270 is totally different. Has big ammunition rooms and entrance defence at the back. I see you get this info from my website Bunkersite. The source is Rudi Rolf. Take this info as a general approach. Local situation can be different. And buy his book Atlantikwall Typologie! It has all the different bunker plans.
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Or that It was made to fit in a bigger canon, the angle of the wall is more or less the same as the wall from a R686 Schartenstand für 19,4 cm
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
quote
The source is Rudi Rolf. Take this info as a general approach. Local situation can be different. And buy his book Atlantikwall Typologie! It has all the different bunker plans.
unquote
Not easy to find in Belgium, uitgeverij De Slegte = sold out
Had also a look for "Atlantikwall Veldboekje", author Pascal Cornel is not found either or also sold out
The source is Rudi Rolf. Take this info as a general approach. Local situation can be different. And buy his book Atlantikwall Typologie! It has all the different bunker plans.
unquote
Not easy to find in Belgium, uitgeverij De Slegte = sold out
Had also a look for "Atlantikwall Veldboekje", author Pascal Cornel is not found either or also sold out
- robin-stahlbeton
- Financial supporter
- Posts: 147
- Joined: 14 May 2007, 22:28
- Location: Arnhem
- Contact:
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Hello
Fortress books?
Rgds
Fortress books?
Rgds
- AvB
- Financial supporter
- Posts: 3425
- Joined: 20 Jun 2004, 01:00
- Location: Utrecht, Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Take a look at Fortress Books. They still have copies. https://www.fortress-books.com/en/catal ... l-typology
- robin-stahlbeton
- Financial supporter
- Posts: 147
- Joined: 14 May 2007, 22:28
- Location: Arnhem
- Contact:
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Thans funny Arthur, at the same time
- AvB
- Financial supporter
- Posts: 3425
- Joined: 20 Jun 2004, 01:00
- Location: Utrecht, Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Hehe, good advertisement for the shop.
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
Thanks, found it also yesterday... a lot of choice !
Re: Stützpunkt 277 MKB York
hi,
I return to the subject. here the bauprogram Fest-Pi stab 11 for the Marine in Festung-cherbourg ... you see the M271 x 7
7 planned and 5 build.
Me belfra-team
I return to the subject. here the bauprogram Fest-Pi stab 11 for the Marine in Festung-cherbourg ... you see the M271 x 7
7 planned and 5 build.
Me belfra-team