Newbie collector - western wall medal

[Carlosdebelen2]

Hello again

Here is another another medal with what is supposed to be an original envelope.


Appreciate your opinion of authenticity.

Thanks

[Carlosdebelen2]

I also got this one which is similar but darker. Any feedback on this too?

[John G.]

Defense Wall/West Wall medal, Late War zink, with short ribbon, in issue envelope. Original, worth $45./65.00 US.
John G.

[Carlosdebelen2]

Thanks again John