border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
I have always been eager to learn how the first years (after the WWII) of the new border between Finland and the SU looked like. bearing in mind these areas were (and are) pretty sparsely populated, I have always imagined there must have been some (if any) contact among both populations. on the flip side, hamlets and settlements are located quite far away from each other so it would be really interesting to learn how people used to get in touch with each other as the border was permanently closed some years later. If you guys have any useful info/links that'd be awesome. thanks a lot
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
I have some information, but, unfortunately, in Russian only.
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
As far as I know Finns evacuated the area that was ceded , like 99.9%. So it is unlikely that there was any contact from Finland to the Soviet side, which was depopulated until Soviet authorities sent immigrants. Also the border was closed or sealed off at once, and guarded well.
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
I studied this question in Säkkijärvi area and interviewed several frontiersmen. They arrived in March 1945 from Vologda. Immigrants lived in very strict conditions and often went to work under escort of borderguards. It was forbidden to lock houses at night, as NKVD often checked documents in nighttime. But all veterans remember about illegal visits of Finns, moreover one old man from Vilajoki told me that one Finn came to their house and asked for food. They had dinner together, then he went on, but was soon arrested by border guards. In 1958 (!) four Russian children from Velikoe (Siissala) crawled under the fence, illegally visited Finland and returned back.
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
Last year Yleisradio (YLE) wrote a story in Finnish of a woman who has lived a few meters from the border since 1954.
Suomalainen isoäiti asuu Venäjän rajaviivalla – Näin kotitalo pelastettiin Neuvostoliiton kaappaukselta
Suomalainen isoäiti asuu Venäjän rajaviivalla – Näin kotitalo pelastettiin Neuvostoliiton kaappaukselta
- Juha Tompuri
- Forum Staff
- Posts: 11562
- Joined: 11 Sep 2002, 21:02
- Location: Mylsä
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
Movie Hopeaa Rajan Takaa (Silver Behind the Border)
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0137003/Summer 1941, soon after the Finnish Winter War. Wist and Anttala are young war veterans whose homes ended up on the wrong side of the new border after the Soviet Union claimed ownership of the Finnish Karelia as a result of the war. The men decide to reclaim a chest full of silver that was hidden under Wist's home before the family was evacuated to Finland. Together with Paukku, a third young man with less experience in risky situations, they cross the border at nighttime and start their dangerous expedition through Soviet terrain.
Trailer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpT_ExSzo_8
Regards, Juha
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
but was the border closed and sealed off right after the war was over? to me, it seems the process of closing and sealing off was a bit like the one between west and east germany, I mean there were some months (years) when the border was practically porous and thus some free movement possible. also, I think some parts of the border weren't changed at all and the population was to some degree intact- except for the Karelian and salla/Petsamo ones ceded to the SU. it is simply hard to imagine that the SU was able to put a fence/make a vista immediately after the war.Lotvonen wrote: ↑06 Nov 2018, 06:59As far as I know Finns evacuated the area that was ceded , like 99.9%. So it is unlikely that there was any contact from Finland to the Soviet side, which was depopulated until Soviet authorities sent immigrants. Also the border was closed or sealed off at once, and guarded well.
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
thanks! wish I had spent more time studying the Finnish language at the university! great pictures - so the upshot of the article is she lived in some sort of exclave in the Russian territory ?Mangrove wrote: ↑06 Nov 2018, 09:37Last year Yleisradio (YLE) wrote a story in Finnish of a woman who has lived a few meters from the border since 1954.
Suomalainen isoäiti asuu Venäjän rajaviivalla – Näin kotitalo pelastettiin Neuvostoliiton kaappaukselta
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
Juha Tompuri wrote: ↑07 Nov 2018, 22:10
Movie Hopeaa Rajan Takaa (Silver Behind the Border)https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0137003/Summer 1941, soon after the Finnish Winter War. Wist and Anttala are young war veterans whose homes ended up on the wrong side of the new border after the Soviet Union claimed ownership of the Finnish Karelia as a result of the war. The men decide to reclaim a chest full of silver that was hidden under Wist's home before the family was evacuated to Finland. Together with Paukku, a third young man with less experience in risky situations, they cross the border at nighttime and start their dangerous expedition through Soviet terrain.
Trailer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpT_ExSzo_8
Regards, Juha
thanks a lot!
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
wow, this story about the kids is really interesting. that guy who was arrested - when did that happen? in the 40s? I am just curious if any SU citizens tried to escape to Finland - I have read somewhere that both countries agreed on sending escapees back to the SU.Swing wrote: ↑06 Nov 2018, 08:02I studied this question in Säkkijärvi area and interviewed several frontiersmen. They arrived in March 1945 from Vologda. Immigrants lived in very strict conditions and often went to work under escort of borderguards. It was forbidden to lock houses at night, as NKVD often checked documents in nighttime. But all veterans remember about illegal visits of Finns, moreover one old man from Vilajoki told me that one Finn came to their house and asked for food. They had dinner together, then he went on, but was soon arrested by border guards. In 1958 (!) four Russian children from Velikoe (Siissala) crawled under the fence, illegally visited Finland and returned back.
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
All information is based on private interviews.knokkelmann1 wrote: ↑08 Nov 2018, 18:36wow, this story about the kids is really interesting. that guy who was arrested - when did that happen? in the 40s? I am just curious if any SU citizens tried to escape to Finland - I have read somewhere that both countries agreed on sending escapees back to the SU.
1.Trip to Finland: I met with one of participants, in 1958 she was 10 years old. Four children came along the forest road to the Finnish village. When they heard an unfamiliar words, they understood that they were in Finland and turned back. In Russia they were arrested by borderguards, but released soon. Commander of frontier post lost his position after this event.
2. Finnish visit to Vilajoki (now Baltiets, about 15 km from borderline). Event was in 1950 or 1951. That time my informer was a little boy, but remember it very well. After dinner together with Russians Finnish guy went to the center of Vilajoki and was arrested there. His further fate is unknown. There are a number of witnesses about Finnish unlegal visits to Säkkijärvi area in the end of 1940s and beginning of 1950s. Similar situation was in other areas of ceded Finnish Karelia.
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
Four children came along the forest road to the Finnish village. When they heard an unfamiliar words, they understood that they were in Finland and turned back. In Russia they were arrested by borderguards, but released soon. Commander of frontier post lost his position after this event.
wow, how did those kids manage to cross the border unnoticed? you mentioned there was a fence (?) and they crawled under I?. how did the physical border look like back then? just a vista? or was it similar to the border between DDR and w germany?
wow, how did those kids manage to cross the border unnoticed? you mentioned there was a fence (?) and they crawled under I?. how did the physical border look like back then? just a vista? or was it similar to the border between DDR and w germany?
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
The farmstead she lived in was never part of an exclave, the Moscow Peace Treaty map was drawn in medium scale map which was open to interpretations. In many places the border was slightly adjusted if the new border would have split villages and farmsteads in half.knokkelmann1 wrote: ↑08 Nov 2018, 18:32great pictures - so the upshot of the article is she lived in some sort of exclave in the Russian territory ?
Here's a dissertation for master's degree related to the topic in hand. Elämää rajavyöhykkeellä: Erityismääräyksien vaikutus rajaseudulla asuneiden elämään vuosina 1944-1954 - Ville Thomsson ("Life in the Border Zone: The Effect of Special Degrees to the Lives of People Living in the Border Region Between 1944 and 1954")
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
There was a barbed tape fence without any alarm system in that time, Photo 1. Border guards periodically walked along the control zone and checked footprints on the sand. You can see remains of old fence at Photo 2, downloaded from Panoramio few years ago. It is a detailed story about illegal crossing of Soviet-Finnish border in 1970s (IN RUSSIAN) based on the book "Escape from Paradise" by Alex Shatravkaknokkelmann1 wrote: ↑09 Nov 2018, 07:39
wow, how did those kids manage to cross the border unnoticed? you mentioned there was a fence (?) and they crawled under I?. how did the physical border look like back then? just a vista? or was it similar to the border between DDR and w germany?
https://ua-antivisa.livejournal.com/117731.html or https://karel500.livejournal.com/26788.html
-
- Member
- Posts: 32
- Joined: 01 Aug 2018, 02:23
- Location: canada
Re: border between Finland and the SU shortly after WWII
thanks a lot for your post.
so this is how the border looked like between Finland and the SU in the south of the border area or some other parts of the border (especially in the north) were virtually unguarded for some time? I have seen a plethora of pictures of the vista and the fence itself but I can hardly imagine the (proper) border fence was erected as early as 1947-1950. in other words, were there any starches of land unguarded, unpatrolled and simply considered to be "desolate" ? just like you said, a forest road lost in taiga...
so this is how the border looked like between Finland and the SU in the south of the border area or some other parts of the border (especially in the north) were virtually unguarded for some time? I have seen a plethora of pictures of the vista and the fence itself but I can hardly imagine the (proper) border fence was erected as early as 1947-1950. in other words, were there any starches of land unguarded, unpatrolled and simply considered to be "desolate" ? just like you said, a forest road lost in taiga...