Reigo -- Drop the hostile tone and personal remarks.
Sure, sure, but I have not been the only one who has engaged in this personal remarks business.
Reigo wrote:Before February 24, 1918 Estonia was independent? Nope. It was a part of Russia.. What govt was in power in Russia? Bolshevik gvt. When the bolshevik gvt lost its power over Estonian territory and why? The bolshevik gvt in Estonia lost its power on that territory because the Brest-Litovsk Peace Treaty was signed on Februaty 18, 1918. According to that Treaty the Russian lands (including the territory of Estonia) were occupied by Germans. in this connection since February 18, 1918 there were no power in Estonia till February 24, 1918. Can I presume that when the Estonian leaders announced the independence of the country on that very day they perfectly understood that the very next day it will be occupied by Germans in accordance with Brest-Litovsk Treaty.
Brest-Litovsk treaty was signed on 3rd March. Before you come to teach Estonians about their history, learn a bit of your own history.The Provisional Gvt was formed when the German occupational regime was still in force in Estonia. Am I right?
No. The government was formed on 24th February and continued work in November when the Germans left.Does it somehow correspond with what is written in your local newspapers?
The arrogance of the ignorant?
I did not justify my actions (since obviously I am guilty), but hinted that judge's actions could be more unbiased. If I am going down then I surely want to grab someone with me. But it seems that one guy has bribed the judge.
(Sorry for the off-topic)
Beppo Schmidt wrote:Revenge is against the people who actually did something wrong to you. I'm sure those soldiers suffered mightily at the hands of those 8-year-old girls.
No official political officers position in Red Army does not mean it does not exist. And for your info, Uncle Iosif reintroduced the dual command back to the Red Army in 1944.
Of course the Red Army does not need any German interference in solving domestic Russikaya problems, i'm implying that the Red Army could be appreciative to the Germans to help them liquidate the commissars because every rank-and-file soldiers in the Red Army hated and despised the political commissars..
Source for every 'rank-and-file' soldier in the Red Army hating Commissars is?
By the way, you should watch Enemy of the Gates..it gives you an idea how political commissars deal with Red Army soldiers
Ah, your source is a movie, one wonders why you post here at all.
So when the group of Estonians proclaimed the independence did they mean to stop the German occupation with the holy word? Or did they know that Estonia would be occupied by Germans? Did the Estonian armed forces fought against Germand or did they support the occupation?
So you mean the gvt was totally formed on February 24, 1918 or that its presence was just announced?
You mean that the same pesonalities (without any additions and alterations) survived till November 1918? So what did they do all that time? I mean the gvt? So the gvt was appointed in February 24, 1918 and then it ..... what? migrated? fought against the occupation? called the people not to follow the orders of Germany? Till the very November 1918?
And then. Who did all the dirty work for the gvt of Piats? Who suppressed the revolt in Revel in November 1918? And who revolted in Revel? Estonians or Russians? And who did suppress them? Russians? Germans?
Interesting that (you are always welcomed to correct me) that the power in Estonia was passed to the Gvt of Piats in November 11, 1918. But the German occupation lasted till November 28, 1918. So it started to operate under ther occupation am I correct?