Early v. Late War Panther & burning easily
-
- Member
- Posts: 282
- Joined: 07 Aug 2005, 18:28
- Location: Raleigh NC
Early v. Late War Panther & burning easily
Hi
Seen alot of reports of the Panther D burning out due to engine problems and ammo & gas storage issues when hit on the side.
Considering how the turrent and chassis were reworked for the A and G models (turrent on A, chassis on G; and G used the newer A turrent), did the Panther get better survivability later in the war?
the engine problems seemed to have been worked out by the end of 1943 or so; but I can't find any reports of the panther burning out easily due to side hits late war. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence however... it could be that it was just an accepted problem, and not note worthy in 1944/5.
I've read Panther by Jentz and skimmed vol 2 of panzertruppen. [I should read panzertruppen vol 2 more closely page by page, but don't really have the time right now...]
Comments?
Seen alot of reports of the Panther D burning out due to engine problems and ammo & gas storage issues when hit on the side.
Considering how the turrent and chassis were reworked for the A and G models (turrent on A, chassis on G; and G used the newer A turrent), did the Panther get better survivability later in the war?
the engine problems seemed to have been worked out by the end of 1943 or so; but I can't find any reports of the panther burning out easily due to side hits late war. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence however... it could be that it was just an accepted problem, and not note worthy in 1944/5.
I've read Panther by Jentz and skimmed vol 2 of panzertruppen. [I should read panzertruppen vol 2 more closely page by page, but don't really have the time right now...]
Comments?
- Christian Ankerstjerne
- Forum Staff
- Posts: 14028
- Joined: 10 Mar 2002, 15:07
- Location: Denmark
- Contact:
-
- Member
- Posts: 282
- Joined: 07 Aug 2005, 18:28
- Location: Raleigh NC
Don't have the Panther book handy, but Jentz has a combat report for one of the panzer divisions which mentions the D had ammo and gas tank exploding problems when hit from the side. I want to say August/October 1943.
And the mechnical reports do indicate the leaky gas tank and fluid issues experienced at Kursk were fixed by fall 1943.
But what abou the ammo/gas tank placement issues?
And the mechnical reports do indicate the leaky gas tank and fluid issues experienced at Kursk were fixed by fall 1943.
But what abou the ammo/gas tank placement issues?
Re: Early v. Late War Panther & burning easily
The problem was never actually corrected, it was more or less swept under the rug and of course was also masked by the Panthers strengths. Allied technical and tactical bulletins pinpointed the vulnerability of the sponson racks and emphasized them as a prime target area through the end of the war. Watch the flick of the Cologne Panthers destruction to see what happens when a Panther takes a round in the side ammo racks, the results are exactly the same as for an early M-4 in the same situation and for T-34 for that matter - flash initial propellent fire (depending upon the number of rounds compromised by the hit), followed by a steady lower intensity burn caused by flamable interior fittings, punctuated by random cookoffs as the heat compromised additional undamaged rounds. Note also the crew reaction, who were obviously well aware of the potential threat caused by such a penetration - get out as soon as possible rather than try to fight back.Epaminondas wrote:the engine problems seemed to have been worked out by the end of 1943 or so; but I can't find any reports of the panther burning out easily due to side hits late war. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence however... it could be that it was just an accepted problem, and not note worthy in 1944/5.
-
- Member
- Posts: 282
- Joined: 07 Aug 2005, 18:28
- Location: Raleigh NC
Kinda suspected that. Heard something about wet storage of the ammo in the later G models, but Jentz doesn't indicate that in my quick flip through...
Have a source on the burning due to side hits in the late war? Primary or secondary would be fine. [going to do a write up for a historical game company]
Have a source on the burning due to side hits in the late war? Primary or secondary would be fine. [going to do a write up for a historical game company]
Epaminondas wrote:Don't have the Panther book handy, but Jentz has a combat report for one of the panzer divisions which mentions the D had ammo and gas tank exploding problems when hit from the side. I want to say August/October 1943.
And the mechnical reports do indicate the leaky gas tank and fluid issues experienced at Kursk were fixed by fall 1943.
But what abou the ammo/gas tank placement issues?
I have a copy of this book. Based on your comments in this thread, it is obvious that you did not read it very carefully.
:::EKB:::
- Reader3000
- Member
- Posts: 2125
- Joined: 10 Nov 2002, 17:01
-
- Member
- Posts: 282
- Joined: 07 Aug 2005, 18:28
- Location: Raleigh NC
- Von Schwerin
- Member
- Posts: 1492
- Joined: 15 Aug 2004, 17:41
- Location: UK
- Contact:
Lots of info here but I can confidently tell you about the flammability of Panthers.
One major problem lay within the carburettors They were prone to flooding. If the engine was stalled or stopped then quickly restarted - the carbs would fllod and ignite over a hot engine. When a Panther was stopped or stalled. A period of grace was needed for the excess fuel to evaporate off. If this didn't happen - the reuslt was an engine bay fire......
How do I know? Why am I so sure? well a friend of mine owns a Panther..... It is under restoration and it will appear within the next 24 months. Another friend has a Jagdpanther. It is newly restored. His Jagdpanther was originally recovered by ANOTHER friend of mine from an MOD firing range at Pirbright UK> This tank came to be there due to this very problem. The driver was using it as a tug to tow a target onto the range..... He had been instructed about the problem. As the JgP came to the bottom of a hill towing its load - it stalled..... The driver was in a hurry and forgot his instuctions..... He quickly restarted the tank and WHOOOSH! Up it went..... So he simply jumped out and let it burn!!!!!! Both tanks were left in situ and became targets.... Years later, my friend recovered the remains of the Jagd for a large UK collector. The tank was sold to Germany and then some years ago (5 I think) she was resold and came back to the UK wher she was restored..... I hope this has gone some way to answering your question.....
Want to see the Jagd?
Nice isn't she?
One major problem lay within the carburettors They were prone to flooding. If the engine was stalled or stopped then quickly restarted - the carbs would fllod and ignite over a hot engine. When a Panther was stopped or stalled. A period of grace was needed for the excess fuel to evaporate off. If this didn't happen - the reuslt was an engine bay fire......
How do I know? Why am I so sure? well a friend of mine owns a Panther..... It is under restoration and it will appear within the next 24 months. Another friend has a Jagdpanther. It is newly restored. His Jagdpanther was originally recovered by ANOTHER friend of mine from an MOD firing range at Pirbright UK> This tank came to be there due to this very problem. The driver was using it as a tug to tow a target onto the range..... He had been instructed about the problem. As the JgP came to the bottom of a hill towing its load - it stalled..... The driver was in a hurry and forgot his instuctions..... He quickly restarted the tank and WHOOOSH! Up it went..... So he simply jumped out and let it burn!!!!!! Both tanks were left in situ and became targets.... Years later, my friend recovered the remains of the Jagd for a large UK collector. The tank was sold to Germany and then some years ago (5 I think) she was resold and came back to the UK wher she was restored..... I hope this has gone some way to answering your question.....
Want to see the Jagd?
Nice isn't she?
- weebobster
- Member
- Posts: 103
- Joined: 10 Nov 2002, 21:18
- Location: United Kingdom
- Tanker Mike
- Member
- Posts: 129
- Joined: 04 May 2004, 16:47
- Location: Indianapolis, Indiana, USA
http://www.sdkfz.com/site/index.php
http://www.sdkfz.com/site/index.phpweebobster wrote:Superb photograph and excellent excellent restoration work. Do you have any more information or pictures about the restoration project itself?
- Tanker Mike
- Member
- Posts: 129
- Joined: 04 May 2004, 16:47
- Location: Indianapolis, Indiana, USA
Jagdpanther Camo
Von Schwerin wrote:Another friend has a Jagdpanther. It is newly restored. His Jagdpanther was originally recovered by ANOTHER friend of mine from an MOD firing range at Pirbright UKYears later, my friend recovered the remains of the Jagd for a large UK collector. The tank was sold to Germany and then some years ago (5 I think) she was resold and came back to the UK wher she was restored
What was the camo based on? The orginal paint scheme of one of the two Jagdpanthers? Do you know what units the two Jagdpanthers belonged to?
Mike
- Von Schwerin
- Member
- Posts: 1492
- Joined: 15 Aug 2004, 17:41
- Location: UK
- Contact:
To answer several questions here...
1 The probablility is that both tanks WILL in fact appear together and if very lucky me and/or my boys will be on them!
2 Thanks Tanker Mike - that is indeed the Foundation's website where their other vehicles can be seen. We only two weeks ago supplied them with a fabulous StK40 in a Sauerkopf which will speed their StuG project up considerably.
3 I have ridden on/in it and it is unbelieveable - The eingine is so...thoroughbred... quiet for such a huge machine!
4 The colour scheme on this Jagd is as per the original. The lines on the edging are where the painters sprayed guidlines in order to get the camo balanced.... Sort of like when you draw a pencil line on a model before spraying it. This is according to the restorer's research an accurate procedure and paint finish. The Jagd is actually a machine from the 116 Panzer Division Der Windhund and the Panther under restoration needs more research but is at present believed to belong to Das Reich. More work needed before absolute certainty can be assured.
Mike - if you are in England and a serious student - Contact the Foundation and arrange a visit. They have strict conditions (Naturally) but you may be pleasantly surprised.
1 The probablility is that both tanks WILL in fact appear together and if very lucky me and/or my boys will be on them!
2 Thanks Tanker Mike - that is indeed the Foundation's website where their other vehicles can be seen. We only two weeks ago supplied them with a fabulous StK40 in a Sauerkopf which will speed their StuG project up considerably.
3 I have ridden on/in it and it is unbelieveable - The eingine is so...thoroughbred... quiet for such a huge machine!
4 The colour scheme on this Jagd is as per the original. The lines on the edging are where the painters sprayed guidlines in order to get the camo balanced.... Sort of like when you draw a pencil line on a model before spraying it. This is according to the restorer's research an accurate procedure and paint finish. The Jagd is actually a machine from the 116 Panzer Division Der Windhund and the Panther under restoration needs more research but is at present believed to belong to Das Reich. More work needed before absolute certainty can be assured.
Mike - if you are in England and a serious student - Contact the Foundation and arrange a visit. They have strict conditions (Naturally) but you may be pleasantly surprised.
- Attachments
-
- Old Von Schwerin Posing in the Sunshine!
- smalpanthpose.JPG (19.36 KiB) Viewed 2149 times