Discussions on the Winter War and Continuation War, the wars between Finland and the USSR.
Hosted by Juha Tompuri
- Posts: 1929
- Joined: 11 Mar 2002 10:03
- Location: Finland
Teemu S wrote: ↑
17 Aug 2018 13:07
I'm thinking of buying Ari Raunio's (et.al) Jatkosodan torjuntataisteluja 1942-1944
, but before I do I'd like to know if anyone who might have the book could tell me how detailed the battle descriptions are? Are battles such as Tali-Ihantala or Ilomantsi described in a day to day fashion? I already own Sotatoimet - Suomen sotien 1939-1945 kulku kartoin
, but I am looking for a similar book that goes in more detail.
I think you are going to be pleased with the particular book. With Tali - Ihantala it does indeed go through the battles day by day. When it comes to Ilomatsi battle, the book does go through it with great detail, although the chain of events get explained in separate chapters presumably due to overlapping events making basic day by day method too complicated. In addition of going through the battle events the book contains excellent maps (which you may already have) and personal histories of commanding officers. The notable thing that it has and that are missing from the older Finnish books is, that it typically has also accurate info about Soviet losses, since authors had access to Russian archives.
EDIT: Typos fixed
Last edited by JTV on 18 Aug 2018 18:03, edited 2 times in total.
- Posts: 17
- Joined: 04 Mar 2016 13:25
- Location: Varkaus, Finland
Thanks Jarkko! I will definitely add it to my collection.
- Posts: 601
- Joined: 25 Jun 2007 11:17
- Location: Finland
Here is an old book :
Taipale "Tavanmukaista tykistötulta"
Otava, Helsinki 1941
202 p in Finnish
The author was an infantry Platoon leader, then a Company commander at Taipale about 15 to 22 February 1940.
I did not (yet) bother to find out which Regiment it was.
The story spans five days the author's platoon held at Koukunniemi field stronghold no.4. What is unique in the story is the "nuts-and-bolts" description of what he did. To begin with 2nd Lt. Simojoki tells the reader what the inside of the dugout looked like when the Company received orders to take over the front line at Koukunniemi. He then describes what he was wearing, how it felt like to get from a warm dugout into very cold night,...In brief, the reader gets an excellent idea what it was like to be a Platoon leader and what his duties were. On the fourth day the Company CO is killed in a counterstrike and 2nd Lt Simojoki is ordered to take over the Company. His unenviable task now is to defend half a kilometer of front line, trenches all smashed up, with a Company - comprising less than 70 (seventy) tired and badly fed men...
Finally he is able to hand over the front line to an outfit comprising inexperienced hastily trained men led by an incompetent officer.
Certainly worth reading.
- Posts: 121
- Joined: 02 Nov 2010 19:32
- Location: kakonkulma
https://mitra-books.com/images/products ... mg_692.jpg
MANNERHEIM LINE ASSAULT - BAIR IRINCHEEV
This book, has anyone read it ?
I`m looking for any info of the troops at Punnus-sector under Winter War. Finnish troops were mostly JR5.
- Posts: 2
- Joined: 24 Jul 2019 11:19
- Location: Helsinki