Frieser's Blitzkrieg Legend is regarded as the reference book about Fall Gelb. Frieser indeed makes a lot of good points, but one particular point always irked me : he seems to overestimate the relative strength in men and material of the Western allies against Germany, claming that « Paradoxically, in May 1940, the defenders were numerically superior to the attacker in almost all areas ».
Manpower
Frieser puts the total manpower of the French army at 6,1 million men in september 1939 reduced to 5,5 millions men in spring 1940. He omits that the latter number includes 960,000 men that were send back to the economy : 710,000 in the industry and 250,000 for the agriculture. This has already been discussed on AHF here: viewtopic.php?f=112&t=248778 Thus French avalaible manpower was closer to 4,385,000. The number of troops deployed on the northeastern front is right though : around 2,230,000.
Frieser overstates the size of the Dutch army : 400,000 when in reality its strength was closer to 280,000 [1]. He also count as deployed on the front the entire Dutch and Belgian forces, when the former aligned only 120,000 men and the latter at best 350,000 (?).
This is a more exact count :
Total manpower : around 7 million Allies vs 5,5 million Germans and not 8,2 vs 5,5.
Total deployed on the northeastern front : 3,2 million Allies vs 3 million Germans and not 3,8 vs 3.
Field artillery
Frieser writes, based on Westfront 1939/40 Erinnerungen des Feindbearbeiters im O.K.H by Ulrich Liss, that Germany had only 7,378 field artillery pieces deployed on the front against 14,000 for the Allies, a large 2 to 1 disadvantage. But, looking at the Heer field artillery piece inventory [2], the Germans had above 13,200 guns. This inventory is not complete though, many types of guns are missing like the 7,7 cm from the Great war or various captured austrian/czech/polish pieces, for a total stock of maybe above 16,000 [3]. To me it's obvious that Liss didn't count infantry guns (like the 7,5 cm IG 18) or the captured weapons in the 7,378 pieces deployed. If the Germans deployed around 75% of their field guns in May 1940 (like the French did), then they had between 9,900 and 12,000 pieces facing 14,000 allies.
Anti-tank guns
Frieser makes no mention of the german superiority in AT weapons : in total 14,257 3,7 cm pieces [2] against around 7,000 25 & 47 mm for the French (4,400 deployed in combat units in metropolitan France) [4]. The Belgians [5] and the Dutch [1] had respectively 750 and 380 47 mm AC guns, the British 850+ guns (?) [6].
[1] http://www.waroverholland.nl/index.php? ... nt-in-wwii
[2] GatSWW 5-IA, p. 636
[3] http://atf40.les-forums.com/topic/41/li ... allemande/
[4] L'armée de Terre française du 10 mai 1940 by Éric Denis p. 175 & 179
[5] https://web.archive.org/web/20121006164 ... elgium.htm
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_E ... ld_War_II)
Correcting Frieser : the force ratio in May 1940
Discussions on WW2 in Western Europe & the Atlantic.
Post Reply
1 post
• Page 1 of 1
Return to “WW2 in Western Europe & the Atlantic”
Jump to
- Axis History
- ↳ Life in the Third Reich & Weimar Republic
- ↳ Propaganda, Culture & Architecture
- ↳ Music of the Reich
- ↳ Women in the Reich
- ↳ Heer, Waffen-SS & Fallschirmjäger
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ U-Boats
- ↳ Kriegsmarine surface ships and Kriegsmarine in general
- ↳ Luftwaffe air units and Luftwaffe in general
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Legion Condor
- ↳ German Strategy & General German Military Discussion
- ↳ NSDAP, other party organizations & Government
- ↳ The Phil Nix SS & Polizei section
- ↳ The Dieter Zinke Axis Biographical Research Section
- ↳ Japan at War 1895-1945
- ↳ Italy under Fascism 1922-1945
- ↳ Minor Axis Nations
- ↳ Finland
- ↳ Foreign Volunteers & Collaboration
- ↳ Holocaust & 20th Century War Crimes
- Axis Equipment
- ↳ Aircraft
- ↳ Fortifications, Artillery, & Rockets
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ The Ron Klages Panzer & other vehicles Section
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Panzer & other vehicles - Photo threads
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Small Arms
- ↳ Other Equipment
- Militaria & Collecting
- ↳ Axis Awards
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ Axis Documents, Feldpost numbers, Postcards & Other Paper Items
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ Axis Uniforms, Headgear & Insignia
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ Other WW1 & WW2 Militaria
- ↳ Militaria for sale
- ↳ For Sale & Wanted
- ↳ Reproductions Sales
- The Allies & the Neutral States
- ↳ China at War 1895-1949
- ↳ France 1919-1945
- ↳ Poland 1919-1945
- ↳ The Soviet Union at War 1917-1945
- ↳ The United Kingdom & its Empire and Commonwealth 1919-45
- ↳ USA 1919-1945
- ↳ The Allies and the Neutral States in general
- World War II and Inter-War Era
- ↳ WW2 in Africa & the Mediterranean
- ↳ WW2 in Eastern Europe
- ↳ WW2 in Western Europe & the Atlantic
- ↳ WW2 in the Pacific & Asia
- ↳ Winter War & Continuation War
- ↳ Spanish Civil War & Legion Condor
- ↳ Economy
- Other Eras
- ↳ First World War
- ↳ Imperial Germany
- ↳ German Colonies and Overseas Expeditions
- ↳ Austria-Hungary 1867–1918
- ↳ The end of the Ottoman Empire 1908-1923
- ↳ Other eras
- Research Help
- ↳ Translation help: Breaking the Sound Barrier
- ↳ Books & other Reference Material
- ↳ Archives
- Other areas
- ↳ Model building
- ↳ Movies, games & other fiction
- ↳ What if
- ↳ Reenactment
- ↳ The Lounge