Tiger tank for Japan?
- Musashi
- Member
- Posts: 4656
- Joined: 13 Dec 2002, 16:07
- Location: Coventry, West Midlands, the UK [it's one big roundabout]
- Contact:
Tiger tank for Japan?
I was watching a film few years ago where I found out Japanese bought German Tiger I tank for 600,000 RM and it was planned to be delivered in parts by a German U-boot. I heard it was delivered and the U-boot's commander was rewarded with a samurai sword for his mission. He was one of three Germans rewarded with samurai swords during WW II.
Some my friends on a Polish historical forum don't agree with that. They claim the Tiger was sold, but not delivered. The microfilms with its plans were delivered only. According to one of guys the exactly price of the Tiger was 645,000 RM.
Please write what you know about this matter.
Regards,
Chris
Some my friends on a Polish historical forum don't agree with that. They claim the Tiger was sold, but not delivered. The microfilms with its plans were delivered only. According to one of guys the exactly price of the Tiger was 645,000 RM.
Please write what you know about this matter.
Regards,
Chris
-
- Member
- Posts: 8267
- Joined: 07 May 2002, 20:40
- Location: Teesside
This Tiger was paid for and sent to Bordeaux for shipment to Japan. However common sense prevailed and it was given as a gift to sSS PzAbt 101 instead. It was used in Normandy. The chassis number of the purchased model was 250455 and thus it would be a rubber wheel model. This would give SS 101 a total of 19 rubber wheel Tigers rather than 20 as Schneider says in TIC II.
-
- Banned
- Posts: 250
- Joined: 29 Dec 2004, 06:14
- Location: Germany
Re: Tiger tank for Japan?
There is a Japanese cartoon book with a delivered Tiger atnk in action against British in Pacific warMusashi wrote:I was watching a film few years ago where I found out Japanese bought German Tiger I tank for 600,000 RM and it was planned to be delivered in parts by a German U-boot. I heard it was delivered and the U-boot's commander was rewarded with a samurai sword for his mission. He was one of three Germans rewarded with samurai swords during WW II.
Some my friends on a Polish historical forum don't agree with that. They claim the Tiger was sold, but not delivered. The microfilms with its plans were delivered only. According to one of guys the exactly price of the Tiger was 645,000 RM.
Please write what you know about this matter.
Regards,
Chris
-
- Banned
- Posts: 250
- Joined: 29 Dec 2004, 06:14
- Location: Germany
- Lt.-Colonel
- Member
- Posts: 204
- Joined: 24 Dec 2004, 00:24
- Location: Croatia,Zagreb
- Unsere_Freiheit
- Member
- Posts: 266
- Joined: 28 Jan 2004, 12:18
- Location: HK
- Contact:
- ancientcoins
- Member
- Posts: 55
- Joined: 27 Apr 2004, 10:27
- Location: Zhengzhou China
Based on the fact that both army of ROC and the Communist Party of China had very few heavy weapons especially tanks,the Tiger to be sent to Japan would have no rivals in the battlefield of China.M4 Shermans,M5 and some other old Russian light tanks in Kuomintang army will not be able to survive the hit of its 8.8cm bounds!!
- Unsere_Freiheit
- Member
- Posts: 266
- Joined: 28 Jan 2004, 12:18
- Location: HK
- Contact:
I agree,but a single Tiger is not invincible when it comes across
i) fighter-bombers or bombers
ii) artillery
iii) Chinese dare-death squads.
iiii) ambushes ,there're lots of forests in China,not only plain fields.
and is it worthy for a Tiger to police the occupied areas? Given that you cannot deploy the Tiger in the Burma forests,and for dealing with Chinese troops, other lighter armored vehicles would be enough as it has been stated above that both Communist and Nationalist armies had very little amount of heavy weapons and tanks.
i) fighter-bombers or bombers
ii) artillery
iii) Chinese dare-death squads.
iiii) ambushes ,there're lots of forests in China,not only plain fields.
and is it worthy for a Tiger to police the occupied areas? Given that you cannot deploy the Tiger in the Burma forests,and for dealing with Chinese troops, other lighter armored vehicles would be enough as it has been stated above that both Communist and Nationalist armies had very little amount of heavy weapons and tanks.
No one is arguing about its capabilities in knocking out other tanks, though Shermans & T34/85's could disable Tigers if they got close enough, and off course many were disabled by hand held infantry weapons. Also if the Allies came up against Tigers in numbers they would employ the weapons which it did historically to destroy it.Based on the fact that both army of ROC and the Communist Party of China had very few heavy weapons especially tanks,the Tiger to be sent to Japan would have no rivals in the battlefield of China.M4 Shermans,M5 and some other old Russian light tanks in Kuomintang army will not be able to survive the hit of its 8.8cm bounds!!
No the real point is that practically the Tiger in Asia would have been a liability. Expensive to produce, high maintenance, fuel gussling, on and unsuitable terrain.
Andy H
U-Boats operated in the Indian Ocean from bases in Singapore, Penang, Batavia (now Jakarta) and Surabaya. Only one U-Boat entered the Pacific, sailing as far as New Zealand. Was it U-852? I could be wrong, that's from memory.
When the Germans surrendered, German crewmen present in these Japanese-held locations were interned, along with their boats. In Indonesia, some ended up fighting it out with pro-independence Indonesians who saw any whites as the enemy.
When the Germans surrendered, German crewmen present in these Japanese-held locations were interned, along with their boats. In Indonesia, some ended up fighting it out with pro-independence Indonesians who saw any whites as the enemy.
-
- Member
- Posts: 784
- Joined: 23 Mar 2004, 01:25
- Location: Wellington, New Zealand
Musashi there were a few U-boats capable of this feat including some Italian boats which became UIT-22, UIT-24, UIT-25 after Italy's surrender. U-219 and U-195 could have performed the feat. Other U-boats to Asia were fighting U-boats unsuited to cargo carrying. I would be fascinated to know any more about this. Remember though that by 1944 Japan was really struggling to get oil shipments from Brunei and Indonesia due to US sub activity.